Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Law Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Osgoode Hall Law School of York University

2009

Discipline
Keyword
Publication
Publication Type

Articles 1 - 30 of 56

Full-Text Articles in Law

The Alberta Legal Services Mapping Project: Report For The Fort Mcmurray Judicial District, Glynnis Lieb, Stephanie Abel, Diana Lowe Dec 2009

The Alberta Legal Services Mapping Project: Report For The Fort Mcmurray Judicial District, Glynnis Lieb, Stephanie Abel, Diana Lowe

Canadian Forum on Civil Justice

The Fort McMurray Judicial District is the second of eleven Alberta Judicial Districts to be mapped as part of the Alberta Legal Services Mapping Project (ALSMP). The ALSMP is a large-scale, 4.5 year endeavour, designed to gain an understanding of the legal needs of Albertans and of the legal services available in Alberta.


The Alberta Legal Services Mapping Project: Report For The Calgary Judicial District, Glynnis Lieb, Stephanie Abel, Mary Stratton, Diana Lowe Dec 2009

The Alberta Legal Services Mapping Project: Report For The Calgary Judicial District, Glynnis Lieb, Stephanie Abel, Mary Stratton, Diana Lowe

Canadian Forum on Civil Justice

The „justice system‟ is a fundamental and far-reaching component of our system of democracy in Alberta. It is not one united system but an institutionalized process to address criminal and civil conflicts. It is made up of a complexity of organizations with overlapping provincial and federal jurisdictions. There are substantive and procedural laws with four broad divisions: civil, family, criminal and administrative. Many of these laws and the legal services associated with them, function to avoid conflict and legal problems. Ideally, legal services work to resolve conflicts without resorting to the courts or tribunals, the purpose of which is to …


Réfugiés Écartés, Sean Rehaag, Francois Crepeau Nov 2009

Réfugiés Écartés, Sean Rehaag, Francois Crepeau

Editorials and Commentaries

No abstract provided.


Normativity, Fairness, And The Problem Of Factual Uncertainty, Andrew Botterell, Christopher Essert Oct 2009

Normativity, Fairness, And The Problem Of Factual Uncertainty, Andrew Botterell, Christopher Essert

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

This article concerns the problem of factual uncertainty in negligence law. We argue that negligence law's insistence that fair terms of interaction be maintained between individuals--a requirement that typically manifests itself in the need for the plaintiff to prove factual or "but-for" causation--sometimes allows for the imposition of liability in the absence of such proof. In particular, we argue that the but-for requirement can be abandoned in certain situations where multiple defendants have imposed the same unreasonable risk on a plaintiff, where the plaintiff suffers the very sort of harm that rendered the risk unreasonable, and where the plaintiff cannot …


Accounting Of Profits To Remedy Biotechnology Patent Infringement, Kuris Andrews, Jeremy De Beer Oct 2009

Accounting Of Profits To Remedy Biotechnology Patent Infringement, Kuris Andrews, Jeremy De Beer

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

A number of important agricultural biotechnology patent disputes have arisen in Canada since the 2004 Supreme Court of Canada decision in Monsanto v. Schmeiser. Typically, defendants no longer contest issues of patent validity or infringement. Instead, the controversies have shifted to discussions about applicable remedies for infringement. The Schmeiser case ostensibly marked a fundamental change in the appropriate method for conducting an accounting of the profits that a defendant infringer must disgorge to a plaintiff patentee. The remedy of accounting of profits in patent cases, however, remains mired in definitional and conceptual confusion, which the Schmeiser case has brought to …


Demythologizing Phosita - Applying The Non-Obviousness Requirement Under Canadian Patent Law To Keep Knowledge In The Public Domain And Foster Innovation, Matthew Herder Oct 2009

Demythologizing Phosita - Applying The Non-Obviousness Requirement Under Canadian Patent Law To Keep Knowledge In The Public Domain And Foster Innovation, Matthew Herder

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

The Supreme Court of Canada recently revised the doctrine of non-obviousness in a pharmaceutical "selection patent" case, Apotex Inc. v. Sanofi-Synthelabo Canada Inc. Although the Court was cognizant of changes to the same doctrine in the United States and the United Kingdom, a critical flaw in how the doctrine is being applied in Canada escaped its attention. Using content analysis methodology, this article shows that Canadian courts frequently fail to characterize the "person having ordinary skill in the art" (PHOSITA) for the purpose of the obviousness inquiry. The article argues that this surprisingly common analytical mistake betrays a deep misunderstanding …


Substantive Review In Appellate Courts Since Dunsmuir, Gerald P. Heckman Oct 2009

Substantive Review In Appellate Courts Since Dunsmuir, Gerald P. Heckman

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

In Dunsmuir v. New Brunswick, the Supreme Court re-examined its approach to judicial review of administrative decisions to develop a "more coherent and-workable" framework. It merged the deferential standards of reasonableness simpliciter and patent unreasonableness into a single reasonableness standard and emphasized the importance of precedent in determining the standard applicable to a specific category of decision makers. The author makes a preliminary assessment of Dunsmuir's impact on judicial review through an analysis of recent Canadian appellate decisions. He concludes that, white Dunsmuir simplifies the standard of review analysis by encouraging courts' reliance on satisfactory precedents and guidelines to determine …


Shared Path: Bridging Indigenous And Settler Notions Of Urban Planning: An Annotated Interview With Carolyn King, Sarah Weinberger Sep 2009

Shared Path: Bridging Indigenous And Settler Notions Of Urban Planning: An Annotated Interview With Carolyn King, Sarah Weinberger

Journal of Law and Social Policy

When Carolyn King was the Chief, the Mississaugas of the New Credit First Nation were in the middle of an almost twenty-five year negotiation of what would be one of the largest specific land claim settlements in Canada’s history. In 1986, the Mississaugas launched a land claim, alleging that the Crown did not comply with the original terms of the Toronto Purchase, taking more land and paying less money than had been agreed upon 200 years earlier. In 2010, Canada agreed to settle for $145 million, deeming lands covering much of Toronto, Burlington Bay, and the Toronto Islands as “traditional …


Community, Property, And Human Rights: The Failure Of Property-As-Respect, Sarah E. Hamill Sep 2009

Community, Property, And Human Rights: The Failure Of Property-As-Respect, Sarah E. Hamill

Journal of Law and Social Policy

The question of whether private property rights can be human rights is longstanding. In this article, I unpack Hanoch Dagan and Avihay Dorfman’s recent attempt to render private property rights as capable of being human rights. Their account of private property forms part of a larger project to re-read private law and argues that the idea of substantive equality is at the heart of private law properly understood. In this article, I critique their focus on the horizontal aspects of property as ignoring the ways in which property always invokes a sense of community. I also argue that Dagan and …


The Complications Of Colonialism For Gentrification Theory And Marxist Geography, Liza Kim Jackson Sep 2009

The Complications Of Colonialism For Gentrification Theory And Marxist Geography, Liza Kim Jackson

Journal of Law and Social Policy

Gentrification is often described metaphorically as a form of ‘colonization,’ however in this paper I argue that gentrification comprises one strategy in the continued historical colonization of Indigenous peoples in the Canadian context, and more specifically in the settler city of Toronto. I propose that the colonial relationalities, both symbolic and material that give rise to the settler city, persist as a discipline on poor and Indigenous bodies, spaces and lands, through the capitalist way of life. Colonial relationalities are again heightened through gentrifications role in Toronto’s strivings for global city status in a neo-imperialist global economy. Gentrification is based …


Making A Music City: The Commodification Of Culture In Toronto’S Urban Redevelopment, Tensions Between Use-Value And Exchange-Value, And The Counterproductive Treatment Of Alternative Cultures Within Municipal Legal Frameworks, Sara Ross Sep 2009

Making A Music City: The Commodification Of Culture In Toronto’S Urban Redevelopment, Tensions Between Use-Value And Exchange-Value, And The Counterproductive Treatment Of Alternative Cultures Within Municipal Legal Frameworks, Sara Ross

Journal of Law and Social Policy

Meaningful diversity and inclusion within today’s cities requires attention on many fronts, including that of city redevelopment strategies and policies. To that end, this article focuses on culture-led regeneration strategies—specifically, those of Toronto’s “Music City” initiative and “Creative City” strategy—and unpacks the mechanics of using culture and heritage as tools for redevelopment where their commodification can reveal the clash between divergent value interests that exist within spaces of culture in the city. Sustainable urban development must carefully account for these divergences to avoid the displacement and lack of equitable accounting of relationally vulnerable individuals, groups, (sub)cultures, and space. Counterproductive effects …


Developers, The State, And The Politics Of Private Property Rights, Donald Leffers Sep 2009

Developers, The State, And The Politics Of Private Property Rights, Donald Leffers

Journal of Law and Social Policy

This article uses a new institutionalist approach to investigate major land use conflicts and regional land use policy changes in the Toronto region that affected the property relations of land developers. Institutionalist approaches focus on the role of key actors, ideas, and strategies in influencing the trajectories of political institutions, and the confrontation of political and strategic maneuvering in the face of existing institutions and structures. Through comparison of the processes driving enactment of two major regional land use statutes—the Oak Ridge Moraine Conservation Act and the Greenbelt Act—this article pays close attention to the relationships between political actors and …


The Properties Of Planning: An Evolving Landscape, Alexandra Flynn, Donald Leffers Sep 2009

The Properties Of Planning: An Evolving Landscape, Alexandra Flynn, Donald Leffers

Journal of Law and Social Policy

The theme of this special volume is “Challenging Traditional Notions of Property in Land Use Planning.” Property in the common law tradition is conceived as a right to something, whether physical or not, that is disconnected from the object or idea itself. Property interests are almost always hierarchical and exclusionary. An emerging body of property law scholarship is challenging the basic tenets of the discipline. For example, Nicole Graham argues that property law must be rooted in a time and place, and Sarah Keenan suggests that property law is a form of spatial and temporal order that can function as …


Revitalizing Land Use Law: Introductory Notes, Ronit Levine-Schnur Sep 2009

Revitalizing Land Use Law: Introductory Notes, Ronit Levine-Schnur

Journal of Law and Social Policy

As a way of celebrating its centenary, I sketch out a vision of how to revitalize land use and zoning law. Such a vision is called for not merely because of the marking of 100 years since zoning was first introduced in New York City. Due to the immense impact land use laws have on human lives and their surroundings, it is crucial to re-imagine the land use law system, and in particular judicial review of land use law, and to ground it within an ethical foundation. A land use law system should be based on an ethical commitment to …


Planning As Property: Uncovering The Hidden Racial Logic Of A Municipal Nuisance By-Law, Heather Dorries Sep 2009

Planning As Property: Uncovering The Hidden Racial Logic Of A Municipal Nuisance By-Law, Heather Dorries

Journal of Law and Social Policy

In her landmark essay, Whiteness as Property, Cheryl Harris powerfully demonstrates how racial identity and property claims are co-produced in law. Through a genealogy of law starting with American slave law, Harris reveals how whiteness has evolved from a form of racial identity into a legally acknowledged and protected form of property. In this article I apply Harris’ framework to an analysis of two by-laws passed by the City of Brantford (Ontario) in 2008, in order to reveal a hidden racial logic within the statutory powers vested in municipalities. By analyzing these by-laws, as well as the litigation which followed, …


Reimagining Toronto’S Community Councils, Alexandra Flynn Sep 2009

Reimagining Toronto’S Community Councils, Alexandra Flynn

Journal of Law and Social Policy

This article examines Toronto’s community councils, a post-amalgamation creation meant to buffer the effects of a much larger city. Using a mixed methodology approach to understand their role and function, this paper finds that community councils largely focus on local planning and land use issues. However, under applicable law, Toronto’s community councils have the capacity to increase their delegated and decision-making power to serve a greater stewardship role in matters of concern to the city’s neighbourhoods, such as the “local” effects of “city-wide” issues, and to include non-councillor members as decision-makers. This paper argues that the City of Toronto should …


Peeking In Cyberspace's Backdoor, James Stribopoulos Jul 2009

Peeking In Cyberspace's Backdoor, James Stribopoulos

Editorials and Commentaries

No abstract provided.


Alberta Legal Services Mapping Project: Action Plan Update, Glynnis Lieb Jul 2009

Alberta Legal Services Mapping Project: Action Plan Update, Glynnis Lieb

Canadian Forum on Civil Justice

In 2006, the Canadian Forum on Civil justice conducted the Self-Represented Litigant (SRL) Mapping Project. This Project aimed to gain a better understanding about SRLs in Alberta, what their legal needs are and what resources are available to them. Mapping for this project was conducted in three sites; Grand Prairie, Red Deer and Edmonton. Findings from this Project were strongly indicative of the lack of public understanding of the justice system and the need for easily accessible public legal information. Based on the recommendations from the SRL Mapping Project, Law Information Centres (LInCs) were established in all three jurisdictions.


Copyright Law And The Restoration Of Beauty, David Nimmer Jul 2009

Copyright Law And The Restoration Of Beauty, David Nimmer

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

No abstract provided.


Peoples, Bce, And The Good Corporate "Citizen", Edward J. Waitzer, Johnny Jaswal Jul 2009

Peoples, Bce, And The Good Corporate "Citizen", Edward J. Waitzer, Johnny Jaswal

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

This article considers the use of various legal instruments to advance a more expansive but well-defined view of directors' duties and discretion--a view which focuses on the longer-term interests of the corporation. We begin with an attempt to clarify the nature of directors' statutory duties under Canadian corporate law. We then consider the recent decisions of the Supreme Court of Canada in Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise and BCE v. 1976 Debentureholders, in which the Court took a broad view of corporate purpose, but failed to provide clear logic or operational guidance as to consequential directorial responsibilities. …


Adding Epicycles: The Inconsistent Use Test In Adverse Possession Law, Michael H. Lubetsky Jul 2009

Adding Epicycles: The Inconsistent Use Test In Adverse Possession Law, Michael H. Lubetsky

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

The common law courts in Ontario developed the Inconsistent Use Test (IUT) to assess claims of adverse possession. The IUT, however, often produces counter-intuitive results, which has led other jurisdictions to reject it and caused the Ontario courts to craft numerous exceptions and qualifications to the test that have left the state of the law on adverse possession very unclear. This article argues that the IUT actually represents an unconscious attempt by the Ontario judiciary to develop a functional equivalent to the civil law principle of "interversion," currently found in article 923 of the Civil Code of Quebec (CCO). It …


From Judging Culture To Taxing "Indians": Tracing The Legal Discourse Of The "Indian Mode Of Life", Constance Macintosh Jul 2009

From Judging Culture To Taxing "Indians": Tracing The Legal Discourse Of The "Indian Mode Of Life", Constance Macintosh

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

In this article I consider how judicial decision making characterizes Indigenous peoples' culture outside the context of determinations under section 35(1) of the Constitution Act, 1982. I am concerned with how contemporary jurisprudence sometimes subjects Indigenous people to stereotyped tests of Aboriginality when they seek to exercise legislated rights. These common law tests of Aboriginality tend to turn on troubling oppositional logics, such as whether or not the Indigenous person engages in waged labour or commercial activities. These tests arose in historic legislation and policy that were premised on social evolutionary theory and were directed at determining whether an Indigenous …


Jurisdiction And Responsibility: Community And The Force Of Law Between Khadr And Amnesty, Craig M. Scott Apr 2009

Jurisdiction And Responsibility: Community And The Force Of Law Between Khadr And Amnesty, Craig M. Scott

All Papers

No abstract provided.


The Supreme Court Of Canada, Charter Dialogue, And Deference, Rosalind Dixon Apr 2009

The Supreme Court Of Canada, Charter Dialogue, And Deference, Rosalind Dixon

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

For those concerned about the democratic legitimacy of Charter review by Canadian courts, the idea of dialogue offers a promising middle path between the extremes of judicial and legislative supremacy. Current dialogue theory, however, largely fails to live up to this promise of compromise. Instead of distinguishing democratic worries associated with US style, strong-form judicial review, it largely endorses the legitimacy of such review. For dialogue to live up to its original promise, a new theory that more clearly distinguishes Canada from the United States is required. This article offers a new theory of dialogue in which the willingness of …


A Tale Of Two Maps: The Limits Of Universalism In Comparative Judicial Review, Adam M. Dodek Apr 2009

A Tale Of Two Maps: The Limits Of Universalism In Comparative Judicial Review, Adam M. Dodek

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

For most of the twentieth century, the dominant paradigm in comparative public law was particularism. This was accompanied by a strong skepticism towards universalist features and possibilities in public law and, especially, constitutional law. With the rise of judicial review after World War I--and especially in Eastern Europe after the collapse of the Soviet Union--comparative judicial review has begun to flourish. However, comparative scholarship on judicial review overemphasizes the centrality of "the question of legitimacy" of judicial review in a democratic polity. This has been a result of the mistaken extrapolation of the American debate over judicial review to other …


Polygamy's Inscrutable Criminal Mischief, Susan G. Drummond Apr 2009

Polygamy's Inscrutable Criminal Mischief, Susan G. Drummond

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

The polygamy charges laid in the settlement of Bountiful, British Columbia, in January 2009, give rise to questions about the particular mischief of the polygamy offence in section 293 of Canada's Criminal Code. This article argues that, as a result of developments within related areas of law, polygamy's mischief under the current wording of the section is virtually inscrutable. When used, this section has principally served as a mechanism to discipline socially and politically marginalized groups. Developments in family law over the last forty years have generated a host of exceptions to the application of the polygamy section, including religious …


Bountiful Voices, Angela Campbell Apr 2009

Bountiful Voices, Angela Campbell

Osgoode Hall Law Journal

Common portrayals of Canada's only openly polygamous community cast it as a space frozen in time, both socially and intellectually. "Bountiful," British Columbia is a sixty-five-year-old community comprised of followers of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints (FLDS). Many residents espouse plural marriage as a central tenet of their faith, believing that the practice leads not only to a good terrestrial life but, also, to facilitated entry into the "celestial kingdom." Visual and written accounts of Bountiful routinely present the women of this community as submissive, silenced, and isolated. Their traditional dress, and the number of …


Kf Modified And The Classification Of Canadian Common Law, F. Tim Knight Mar 2009

Kf Modified And The Classification Of Canadian Common Law, F. Tim Knight

Librarian Publications & Presentations

This article was inspired by a previous article written by Vincent DeCaen in an earlier issue of CLLR. It explores classification, the different approaches taken by KF Modified and LC Class KE, and the role KF Modified has had in organizing collections in Canadian law libraries. It argues that there is no right or wrong way to classify legal resources and suggests that KF Modified can benefit cataloguing workflow and is well suited to both the Canadian and common law library environments.


The Administration Of Canada’S Transfer Pricing Rules: Issues And Recommendations, Jinyan Li, Pierre Barsalou, John Oatway, François Vincent Jan 2009

The Administration Of Canada’S Transfer Pricing Rules: Issues And Recommendations, Jinyan Li, Pierre Barsalou, John Oatway, François Vincent

Commissioned Reports, Studies and Public Policy Documents

No abstract provided.


Book Review: The Human Rights System, Activist Forces And International Institutions By Obiora Chinedu Okafor, Yemisi Dina Jan 2009

Book Review: The Human Rights System, Activist Forces And International Institutions By Obiora Chinedu Okafor, Yemisi Dina

Librarian Publications & Presentations

No abstract provided.