Law Commons^™

A State Law Approach To Preserving Fair Use In Academic Libraries, David R. Hansen

David R Hansen

The Promise Principle And Contract Interpretation, Juliet P. Kostritsky

Juliet P Kostritsky

The promise principle and its roots in a certain type of morality of individual obligation, which play the central role in Charles Fried’s vision of Contract law, have importantly contributed to rescuing Contract law from absorption into Tort law and from the imposition of externally imposed standards that are collective in origin. It makes a mammoth contribution to alerting us to the tyranny of interference with individual self-determination. However, this essay questions whether a promise centered system derived from a moral philosophy of promising (without an observable and testable foundation in reality) and geared to internal individual obligation and duty …

Damages To Business Interests, R. Steven Thing

R. Steven Thing

No abstract provided.

Contract + Tort = Property: The Trade Secret Illustration, Matthew E. Cavanaugh Mba Cpa Esq.

Matthew E. Cavanaugh MBA CPA Esq.

This article commences with an introduction to the use of Hegel’s famous dialectical method as an arithmetic analysis of law. It reviews Hegel’s assertion that the sum of property and contract is tort and crime, and then suggests a better dialectic is that contract plus tort equals property. This article then reviews the doctrines of contract, tort, and property, focusing on the plaintiff’s rights and remedies, and who can be defendants in each of the three doctrines. The article next reviews the law of one particular type of intellectual property, trade secrets, because this article uses trade secrets as a …

Development Lending To Municipalities By The World Bank Group, Asheesh Bhalla

Asheesh Bhalla

The World Bank Group has recently shifted its development lending policies to have a greater focus on lending to municipalities and developing financial institutions and systems of market creation at the local level. The author reviews this policy shift, and the consequences of such policy changes on local government institutions and law.

Is Privity Dead? Should It Be?, David F. Tavella

David F. Tavella

Privity, a concept that is over 150 years old, may have worked well in the 19th Century, seems outdated in a time national accounting firms and law firms. In the 19th and early 20th Centuries, when a person may have gone to an agent, accountant, or other service provider for advice, there was no thought that the advice would be distributed to potentially millions of people with the possibility of billions of dollars in losses for negligent performance. Today, this is common in the accounting and insurance industries. The question is whether a concept, even one firmly rooted in American …

Judicial Intervention As Risk Reduction, Juliet P. Kostritsky

Juliet P Kostritsky

JUDICIAL INTERVENTION AS RISK REDUCTION J. P. Kostritsky Employing an economics-based consequentialist approach to contract interpretation (focusing on the prospective effect and the factors that might justify intervention) this Article attempts to identify the precise parameters of an optimal framework for contract interpretation. Such a framework would seek to maximize gains from trade. The issue in such cases is always, given the words the parties used, what is the best (surplus maximizing) interpretation of the bargain. Courts can achieve that interpretation by, in part, minimizing the interpretive risk that parties face when they draft an express contract but fail to …

Social Media And The Rise In Consumer Bargaining Power, Wayne Barnes

Wayne Barnes

Consumers are constantly entering into form contracts, both offline and online. They do not read most of the terms, but the duty to read says the contracts are nevertheless fully enforceable. Moreover, consumers lack any real bargaining power when assenting to such contracts with merchants. Not only that, but if the products malfunctions, or they are somehow damaged by it, they will likely face the prospect of being limited in their available remedies because of boilerplate terms which are favorable to the merchant. In the “old days,” the consumer had no real recourse but to call a 1-800 number, and …

Social Media And The Rise In Consumer Bargaining Power, Wayne Barnes

Wayne Barnes

Consumers are constantly entering into form contracts, both offline and online. They do not read most of the terms, but the duty to read says the contracts are nevertheless fully enforceable. Moreover, consumers lack any real bargaining power when assenting to such contracts with merchants. Not only that, but if the products malfunctions, or they are somehow damaged by it, they will likely face the prospect of being limited in their available remedies because of boilerplate terms which are favorable to the merchant. In the “old days,” the consumer had no real recourse but to call a 1-800 number, and …

Social Media And The Rise In Consumer Bargaining Power, Wayne Barnes

Wayne Barnes

Consumers are constantly entering into form contracts, both offline and online. They do not read most of the terms, but the duty to read says the contracts are nevertheless fully enforceable. Moreover, consumers lack any real bargaining power when assenting to such contracts with merchants. Not only that, but if the products malfunctions, or they are somehow damaged by it, they will likely face the prospect of being limited in their available remedies because of boilerplate terms which are favorable to the merchant. In the “old days,” the consumer had no real recourse but to call a 1-800 number, and …

Social Media And The Rise In Consumer Bargaining Power, Wayne Barnes

Wayne Barnes

Consumers are constantly entering into form contracts, both offline and online. They do not read most of the terms, but the duty to read says the contracts are nevertheless fully enforceable. Moreover, consumers lack any real bargaining power when assenting to such contracts with merchants. Not only that, but if the products malfunctions, or they are somehow damaged by it, they will likely face the prospect of being limited in their available remedies because of boilerplate terms which are favorable to the merchant. In the “old days,” the consumer had no real recourse but to call a 1-800 number, and …

A Consequentialist Approach To Interpretation, Probabilistic Mechanisms, And Risk: Let’S Not Limit Courts’ Techniques Of Common Law Adjudication; Rethinking Judicial Intervention From Contracts To The Chrysler Bankruptcy, Juliet P. Kostritsky

Juliet P Kostritsky

Employing an economics-based consequentialist approach to contract interpretation (focusing on the prospective effect and the factors that might justify intervention) this Article attempts to identify the precise parameters of an optimal framework for contract interpretation. Such a framework would seek to maximize gains from trade. The issue in such cases is always, given the words the parties used, what is the best (surplus maximizing) interpretation of the bargain. Courts can achieve that interpretation by, in part, minimizing the interpretive risk that parties face when they draft an express contract but fail to completely resolve all possible issues. This Article uses …

Social Media And The Rise In Consumer Bargaining Power, Wayne R. Barnes

Wayne R. Barnes

Rhetoric, Reality & The Wrongful Abrogation Of The Collateral Source Rule In Personal Injury Cases., Lori A. Roberts

Lori A Roberts

RHETORIC, REALITY & THE WRONGFUL ABROGATION OF THE COLLATERAL SOURCE RULE IN PERSONAL INJURY CASES. LORI A. ROBERTS Abstract: There are few certainties in litigation, but one that any injured plaintiff with health care insurance can rely on is that a defendant-tortfeasor will argue that the plaintiff’s health care bills are “illusory” and that the plaintiff will recover a “windfall” if he is allowed to recover the full amount of those bills as economic damages. The issue addressed in this Article, whether the difference between the billed rate for medical care and the actual amount paid by a plaintiff’s insurer …

Testamentary Substitutes: Retained Interests, Custodial Accounts And Contractual Transactions—A New Approach, Sidney Kwestel, Rena C. Seplowitz

Rena C. Seplowitz

No abstract provided.

Huch V. Charter Communications Inc.: Consumer Prey, Corporate Predators And A Call For The Death Of The Voluntary Payment Doctrine Defense, Oliver T. Beatty

Oliver T Beatty

This article addresses the collision between consumer fraud statutes, which developed in the last forty years, and the voluntary payment doctrine, which dates back to the 1600’s. The voluntary payment doctrine (“VPD”) provides, in its most common form, that “absent fraud or duress, a person who pays with full knowledge of all the facts cannot recover the money back again.” This doctrine holds true even if the money is not legally owed, and in some cases, even if the payment is made under protest. Conversely, consumer fraud statutes typically allow consumers to recover damages in a broad range of contexts, …

Aplicaciones Prácticas Del Behavioral Law And Economics: ¿Superando Sesgos Cognitivos?, Renzo E. Saavedra Velazco

Renzo E. Saavedra Velazco

En las últimas décadas los postulados del Law and Economics tradicional han venido sufriendo una serie de acotaciones por parte de los académicos de las denominadas ciencias conductuales. A pesar de las pruebas empíricas que se ofrecen para sustentar las objeciones elevadas, un sector tradicionalista se empeña, una y otra vez, en alegar la poca utilidad de esta visión alternativa. Es por esta razón que se reseñarán algunas de sus posibles aplicaciones.

No More Abuse: The Dodd-Frank And Consumer Financial Protection Act's "Abusive" Standard, Tiffany S. Lee

Tiffany S Lee

The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Financial Protection Act creates the new Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection. This consumer watchdog will be responsible for the most powerful consumer protections in American history. Under section 1031(d) of the Act, the Bureau may ban acts and practices that are unfair, deceptive, or abusive. While the unfair and deceptive standards have existed for some time, “abusive” is a relatively new legal standard with limited jurisprudential history. Thus, ironically, critics assert that the inclusion of the abusive standard is itself an abuse of legislative power. This Article asserts that despite some criticism to …

Re-Conceptualizing The Law Of Nuisance Through A Theory Of Economic Captivity, George P. Smith

George P Smith

Re-conceptualizing the Law of Nuisance through a Theory of Economic Captivity

George P. Smith, II

Matthew Saunig

Abstract:

Generally, the fact that a plaintiff comes to a nuisance is not a per se defense to a nuisance action. This defense is viewed in many jurisdictions as but a factor in determining whether a defendant’s conduct is an unreasonable interference with use and enjoyment of a neighbor’s property. In principle, two other affirmative defenses are—although not often allowed in practice by the courts—found in contributory negligence and assumption of the risk.

This Article seeks to develop a theory of economic captivity …

All Your Eggs In One Basket: Why Contract Law Proves Unreliable In Frozen Embryo Adoption Cases, Austin R. Caster

Austin R Caster

This article will show why infertile couples cannot unequivocally rely on good faith, consensual contracts in cases of assisted reproductive technology because the law is so unsettled. Each section will show why, because of alleged public policy implications, contract doctrines or clauses such as (1) the termination of parental rights, (2) the doctrine of waste, and (3) liquidated damages still remain almost completely unreliable in a matter regarding assisted reproductive technology. Though this uncertainty affects infertile couples trying to complete their families through various methods including adoption, surrogacy, in vitro fertilization, and artificial insemination, this article will focus on cases …

Antitrust In The Skies: The United And Olympic Airline Mergers, Justin Dickerson

Justin Dickerson

This Article explores the 2010 merger of United Airlines and Continental Airlines—which usurped Delta’s briefly-held title as the world’s largest airline—as well as the failed merger of Greece’s two largest airlines, Olympic Air and Aegean Airlines, and the antitrust considerations associated with each of these transactions. Part II of this Article details the United and Continental merger, explaining pertinent portions of each airline’s corporate history over the past 10 years, which has included multiple other unsuccessful merger attempts. Next, Part III describes the circumstances surrounding the failed combination of Olympic and Aegean, including the role the Greek financial crisis played …

Enforceability Of Forum Selection Clauses: A "Gallant Knight" Still Seeking Eldorado, Nathan M. Crystal, Francesca Giannoni-Crystal

Nathan M. Crystal

Forum selection clauses (“FSC”) are very common in both domestic and international contracts. In Bremen v. Zapata Off-Shore Company (“Bremen”), 407 U.S. 1 (1972), the Supreme Court established basic standards for the enforceability of such clauses. Relying on Bremen standards, courts today generally enforce FSC. However, the vagueness of Bremen standards leaves room for a party to resist enforcement. The result may be delay and inefficiency. The Supreme Court has said that arbitration clause is a form of FSC, but it has applied different standards for the enforcement of arbitration clauses from FSC. This article argues for a reformulation of …

Preface To The Gateway Thread, Deborah W. Post

Deborah W. Post

No abstract provided.

A Deposit Substitute For Post Dodd-Frank Regulatory Policy Assessments Of Emergent Payments: A Taxonomical Approach, Eniola Akindemowo

Eniola Akindemowo

Existing stored value products (SVPs) are early prototypes of what payments and money will become: digital, disintermediated, and, possibly, neither state- nor bank-issued. The formulation of stored value regulatory policy in the U.S. has been a complicated, slow process however, producing a piecemeal scheme of broadly uneven regulations. Suffice it to say that the result of several short-term fixes has been to postpone looming inefficiencies and highlight limitations stemming from inconsistencies inherent in their use.

Past regulatory efforts have thrown a startling fact into sharp relief: The relevance of deposits, the hallowed central concept of payments jurisprudence, is undermined in …

The Interplay Between U.S. Statutory Rights And Public Policy Under The Faa And New York Convention In International Disputes, Daniel Schwarz

Daniel M. Schwarz

The “prospective waiver” doctrine allows U.S. courts to invalidate or sever arbitration clauses in otherwise valid agreements to arbitrate where arbitrating under foreign law would prevent a U.S. party from seeking relief under a U.S. statute. The loss of this opportunity is said to affront U.S. public policy. This paper acknowledges that courts’ application of this idea has resulted in the need for a more fundamental revisiting of the question of whose law should be “mandatory” in international arbitration. But more specifically, this paper proposes appropriate sets of factors for pre-arbitration courts, arbitrators, and post-arbitration enforcement courts to consider in …

Testamentary Substitutes: Retained Interests, Custodial Accounts And Contractual Transactions—A New Approach, Sidney Kwestel, Rena C. Seplowitz

Sidney Kwestel

No abstract provided.

Patent Assignments By Employees Demand Better Protections, Chuan Ai

Chuan D Ai

Two problems make it nearly impossible for a buyer of patent rights – either as an assignee or a licensee – to know if the title is clean. First, there is no single central registry where all economic rights to patents are stored and searched. Patent assignments and licenses may be recorded at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, merely as an option. More significantly, for the vast majority of inventors in the U.S. who are employed and obligated to assign their future patents invented on the job, there is no way to record such pre-invention assignments. To remedy this …

False Security: How Securitization Failed To Protect Arrangers And Investors From Borrower Claims, Kathleen C. Engel, Thomans J. Fitzpatrick

kathleen c engel

False Security: How Securitization Failed to Protect Arrangers and Investors from Borrower Claims

by Kathleen C. Engel and Thomas J. Fitzpatrick IV

The future of housing finance is in a state of flux. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the two largest loan arrangers in the United States, are in conservatorship. Private sector securitization of mortgages has almost completely stopped. As a result, Fannie, Freddie and Ginnie Mae now own or guarantee almost all new residential mortgage loans. In February 2011, the Obama Administration released a proposal outlining three plans for the future of housing finance. In all three plans, Freddie …

Patent Assignments By Employees Demand Better Protections, C. David Ai

Chuan D Ai

In the decision of Stanford v. Roche, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit focused on the assignment clause in two contracts signed by the same inventor, and compared the language of “I will assign and do hereby assign” (in Cetus/Roche’s contract) against “I agree to assign” (in Stanford’s contract). The Federal Circuit failed to examine the completely different contexts of the two contracts -- Roche’s Visitor’s Confidentiality Agreement versus Stanford’s Employment Invention Assignment Agreement -- thus suggesting that an assignment clause in any contract carries the same weight. Increasingly, IP assignment language appears in a variety of contracts, …

Recalibrating Abstract Payments Regulatory Policy: A Retrospective After The Dodd-Frank Act, Eniola Akindemowo

Eniola Akindemowo

The future efficiency of the payments system is at stake. Existing stored value products (SVPs e.g. gift cards and gift card apps) are early prototypes of what payments and money will become – digital, dis-intermediated, and possibly, neither state nor bank issued. These products have defied sustained efforts to pigeonhole them into traditional categories. Significantly, past regulatory efforts have thrown a startling fact into sharp relief: the relevance of deposits – the hallowed central concept of payments jurisprudence – is being undermined in SVPs and emergent payments. What this means is that the role of deposits – the lynch pin …