Law Commons^™

Liberty's Equal?: An Essay On Property's Rhetoric, Steven Semeraro

Steven Semeraro

Legal analysis of the compensation problem in Takings law has shifted its focus from the welfare economics and traditional philosophy to a more or less self-conscious linguistic investigation of the rhetorical devices used to convey the concept of property through language. Insight comes from understanding the signs and categories that our society uses to communicate about and understand property, rather than from a comprehensive view of what is best for society. This essay focuses on a partially concealed rhetorical device that has been repeatedly used by courts to justify the appropriateness of compensating individuals whose property loses some value as …