Law Commons^™

Race And American Indian Tribal Nationhood, Matthew L.M. Fletcher

Matthew L.M. Fletcher

American Indian tribes and nations are at a crossroads. One on hand, many tribes like the Cherokee Nation – mired in the politics and law of disenfranchising the Cherokee Freedmen – continue to hold to a citizenry based in race and ancestry. Federal Indian law tends to protect, and encourage, even the worst abuses of this regime. The United States long has adopted Indian blood quantum as a proxy for tribal citizenship, creating unfortunate paradoxes for Indian tribes and their citizens. For example, the Supreme Court just a few days ago in Carcieri v. Salazar held against an Indian tribe …

Race And American Indian Tribal Nationhood, Matthew L.M. Fletcher

Matthew L.M. Fletcher

As American Indian tribal nations develop the capacity to govern their own citizens, and engage in substantial economic and political activities with non-citizens, they are heading toward major roadblocks. Tribal nations, like other nations, seek to regulate the activities of all persons within their territorial jurisdictions, including the power to tax and prosecute those persons, citizen or not. The United States Supreme Court has expressed strong skepticism about the possibility of tribal nations asserting this authority and has placed tight controls on the authority of tribal nations to regulate the activities of non-tribal citizens.

Tribal governments are nations and should …