Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Law Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Articles 1 - 23 of 23

Full-Text Articles in Law

Shareholder Compensation As Dividend, James J. Park Dec 2009

Shareholder Compensation As Dividend, James J. Park

Michigan Law Review

This Article questions the prevailing view that securities-fraud actions suffer from a circularity problem. Because shareholder plaintiffs are owners of the defendant corporation, it is commonly argued that shareholder compensation is a payment from shareholders to themselves with substantial transaction costs in the form of attorney fees. But shareholder compensation is no more circular than a dividend, which is a cash payment to shareholders from the company they own with substantial transaction costs in the form of taxes. In fact, shareholder compensation is less circular than a dividend because it is a transfer to shareholders who purchased stock when the …


Trusts-Restraints On Alienation-Invalidity Of Voting Trust Wherein Voting Trust Certificates Were Made Inalienable, W. P. Sutter S.Ed. Mar 1950

Trusts-Restraints On Alienation-Invalidity Of Voting Trust Wherein Voting Trust Certificates Were Made Inalienable, W. P. Sutter S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Two stockholders, controlling a majority of the class B stock of the X corporation, transferred their stock to themselves jointly as trustees for a ten-year period. The trustees were to vote the stock as a unit, and had full voting powers on all matters affecting the corporation. Trustees agreed not to transfer the stock without the approval of both holders, and the holders agreed not to sell their stock or the voting trust certificates. Moreover, on the death of one holder-trustee, the other had an option to purchase all his interest in the stock. In an action in equity to …


Corporations--By-Laws--Restrictions On Transfer Of Bank Stock, Hugh B. Muir Dec 1949

Corporations--By-Laws--Restrictions On Transfer Of Bank Stock, Hugh B. Muir

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff received thirty shares of bank stock by bequest. Before she presented the shares to the bank for transfer, the stockholders, by a majority vote (plaintiff dissenting), amended the by-laws so as to limit to certain classes the persons to whom the bank stock could be transferred, whether by transfer inter vivos, will, or descent. A mandamus proceeding was initiated against the bank to compel a transfer of the shares free of the restrictions. On defendants' appeal from a ruling denying a motion to quash an alternative writ, held, affirmed. The restrictions sought to be imposed were not authorized …


Corporations-Effect Of Merger Upon Apparent Rights Of Stockholders Under Preferred Stock Contracts, Charles M. Soller S.Ed. Jan 1948

Corporations-Effect Of Merger Upon Apparent Rights Of Stockholders Under Preferred Stock Contracts, Charles M. Soller S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

It is the purpose of this comment to examine the effect of merger upon some of the provisions of the preferred stock contract.


Corporations--Transfer Of Shares--Restriction By Shareholders' Agreement, John E. Grosboll Apr 1947

Corporations--Transfer Of Shares--Restriction By Shareholders' Agreement, John E. Grosboll

Michigan Law Review

The original shareholders of a family corporation had entered into a private agreement, noted on the stock certificates, which provided that before sale by any of the parties of any stock to a non-member, such stock must first be offered to the remaining stockholders. Defendant B, the widow of one of the founders, contracted to sell her stock to plaintiff, a non-member, without first offering it to defendants L and M, who own the balance of the stock. Plaintiff now seeks specific performance of his contract with defendant B. Defendants L and M seek to exercise their …


Corporations--Amendment Of By-Laws By Custom, Cornelia Groefsema S.Ed. Mar 1947

Corporations--Amendment Of By-Laws By Custom, Cornelia Groefsema S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

In an application for a preliminary injunction to prevent stockholders from exercising their rights of ownership until there had been a determination whether such stock should be cancelled because issued without corporate authorization, the success of the petitioner depended upon whether a quorum of the directors was present at the meeting authorizing its issuance. This in turn depended upon whether the by-law requiring a board of directors of ten members had been amended by custom to require only seven. For the four years preceeding the meeting at which the stock was authorized, during which time, however, there were neither directors' …


Corporations-Extent Of Powers To Dispose Of Property In Winding Up Its Affairs Under Statutes Extending Corporate Existence, Joseph R. Brookshire S.Ed. Apr 1946

Corporations-Extent Of Powers To Dispose Of Property In Winding Up Its Affairs Under Statutes Extending Corporate Existence, Joseph R. Brookshire S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

According to the common law a dissolved corporation ceased to exist for all purposes. Whether the dissolution was voluntary or involuntary, the effect of the dissolution was to deprive the corporation of all powers either de jure or de facto. It was necessary, therefore, that corporations facing dissolution proceed without delay toward a final liquidation and distribution of assets. Disregarding the old theory that personal property of dissolved corporations escheated to the state, and that its real estate reverted to the original granter or his heirs, and that debts due the corporation were extinguished, it is still apparent that hurried …


Abstracts, Mary Jane Plumer Feb 1945

Abstracts, Mary Jane Plumer

Michigan Law Review

The abstracts consist merely of summaries of the facts and holdings of recent cases and are distinguished from the notes by the absence of discussion.


Corporate Proxies, Leonard H. Axe Aug 1942

Corporate Proxies, Leonard H. Axe

Michigan Law Review

The earlier forms of corporations in England seem to have been political units and the normal mode of conferring corporate rights was by an issue of a charter from the crown, whereby a body of individuals was designated a corporation with the sovereign power to exercise appropriate privileges. Since the charter was issued by the crown, the corporation was considered a part of the government and each member of the corporation was entitled to one vote if given by him in person. As one writer has so well stated, this "was the result of a political philosophy which assumed that …


Corporations - Reserved Powers - Abrogation Of Preferred Dividend Arrearages By Charter Amendment, Merger, Or Consolidation, William D. Sutton May 1941

Corporations - Reserved Powers - Abrogation Of Preferred Dividend Arrearages By Charter Amendment, Merger, Or Consolidation, William D. Sutton

Michigan Law Review

The "malignant" decision in the Dartmouth College case fathered the passage of reserved-power statutes in virtually all the states. These statutes, in turn, when opposed by the retaliatory fundamental-rights safeguards invoked by the courts for the protection of corporate stockholders, procreated problems which have grown more baffling and incorrigible with age. Not the least among these are proposed changes in the liabilities or rights of stockholders, especially the attempted abolition of unpaid accrued dividends upon cumulative preferred stock where there exists a surplus which might lawfully be applied to the payment of such dividends.


Bankruptcy-Corporate Reorganization-Publicly Held Securities As A Test Of Availability Of Relief Under Chapters X And Xi Of The Chandler Act, Edward S. Biggar Nov 1940

Bankruptcy-Corporate Reorganization-Publicly Held Securities As A Test Of Availability Of Relief Under Chapters X And Xi Of The Chandler Act, Edward S. Biggar

Michigan Law Review

Chapter X of the amended Bankruptcy Act of 1938 was mainly the product of the investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission of reorganization practices under the old equity procedure and under section 77B. The chief aim of the sponsors of this new chapter was to preclude the control of reorganization proceedings by "inside" groups, and thereby more adequately protect the interests of investors. Contemporaneously with the overhauling of section 77B, however, other sections of the old Bankruptcy Act were being revised. Among the changes effected, old sections 12 and 74, dealing with extensions and compositions, were remodelled and combined …


Corporations -Parent And Subsidiary-Right Of Parent Or Subsidiary To Share With Other Creditors In Assets Of Associated Corporation On The Latter's Insolvency, Collins E. Brooks Jan 1939

Corporations -Parent And Subsidiary-Right Of Parent Or Subsidiary To Share With Other Creditors In Assets Of Associated Corporation On The Latter's Insolvency, Collins E. Brooks

Michigan Law Review

Increasingly in the past few years, courts throughout the country have seemed willing to disregard what Professor Ballantine has called the "basic theory of corporation law," the concept that a corporation is an entity entirely distinct and separate from its stockholders. It is not the purpose of this writer to take issue with this tendency; for the most part the decisions seem sound and the results just. It is believed, however, that the rules used by the courts in reaching those decisions are, in many instances, open to question. There is one situation in particular in which the courts have …


Corporations - Disregarding Corporate Entity - Fraud, Collins E. Brooks Dec 1938

Corporations - Disregarding Corporate Entity - Fraud, Collins E. Brooks

Michigan Law Review

A and B purchased from plaintiffs all of the stock of defendant corporation. Prior to the transaction, and as a basis for negotiations, plaintiffs had an accountant prepare a statement of corporate assets and liabilities, which showed that the corporation was in financial difficulties. A and B acknowledged the corporate indebtedness and took over the corporation. Later, plaintiffs brought suit against the corporation on claims for salaries and advancements allegedly due them from it, which claims had not appeared on the statement of corporate liabilities. Held, the corporate entity would be disregarded, and plaintiffs estopped from setting up their …


Taxation - Federal Income Tax - Payment To Employees As Compensation Or Gift, Ralph Winkler Jun 1938

Taxation - Federal Income Tax - Payment To Employees As Compensation Or Gift, Ralph Winkler

Michigan Law Review

The Universal Oil Products Company had been "extraordinarily successful," and its interests were very large and valuable. The stockholders transferred their stock to another corporation and the cash assets to the Unopco Corporation, an organization formed for the express purpose of managing this fund, whose stockholders were the same as of the former Universal Oil Products Company. At a stockholders' meeting, a resolution was adopted which in effect provided that a sum of money be allocated for payment to those employees who had loyally supported the former company. At the time this resolution was adopted the president of the new …


Bankruptcy - Corporate Reorganization - Plan - Adequate Protection Of Claims - Due Process, Erwin S. Simon Apr 1937

Bankruptcy - Corporate Reorganization - Plan - Adequate Protection Of Claims - Due Process, Erwin S. Simon

Michigan Law Review

In proceedings for reorganization under Section 77B of the Bankruptcy Act, the debtor held real property valued at $245,025, while outstanding against the property there were first mortgage bonds of $445,000, second mortgage notes for $40,250 and a third mortgage note for $27,000. The court confirmed a plan which made no provision for junior lienors or stockholders, and to which they had not given their consent. On certiorari, granted by the Supreme Court, it was held, that since there was no equity in the property above the first mortgage, the claims of the junior lienors and stockholders had no …


Contempt - Suppression Order - Publication Of Contents Of Suppressed File, Milton M. Howard Jan 1937

Contempt - Suppression Order - Publication Of Contents Of Suppressed File, Milton M. Howard

Michigan Law Review

On a bill of complaint being filed in chancery court an injunction was issued against the defendant therein, and the papers in the cause were ordered suppressed by the chancellor, and to that end, sealed in an envelope. The bill alleged misrepresentation on the part of a leading banker in getting stockholders to contribute toward making up the defalcations of other officers in the bank and malfeasance of other officers. Defendant newspaper reporter obtained information relative to the allegations in the bill from sources other than the suppressed file and published the same nine months later. Upon citation for contempt, …


The Corporate Entity As A Solvent Of Legal Problems, Elvin R. Latty Mar 1936

The Corporate Entity As A Solvent Of Legal Problems, Elvin R. Latty

Michigan Law Review

If a layman were to ask a lawyer what is the reason that a stockholder is ordinarily not liable for his corporation's debts or that a deed to corporate property by the sole stockholder in his own name is not a flawless conveyance, the answer the layman would get would be: a corporation is a wholly different person from its stockholders-it is an entity separate and distinct from them. That answer reveals the traditional approach to scores of problems in corporation law, an approach which, it is submitted, can lead the incautious into considerable trouble.


Corporations - Liability Of Directors To Creditors For Negligent Management Feb 1936

Corporations - Liability Of Directors To Creditors For Negligent Management

Michigan Law Review

There is much confusion in the cases concerning a director's liability to a creditor for negligent management of the corporation. A clearer answer might be indicated by an examination of analogous situations involving individuals instead of corporations. It adds confusion to the law to have a different rule for a corporation than for a human being, and such a result should be avoided unless separate treatment is required by something inherent in the corporation. The least that can happen if a court thinks along these lines is that it will be more likely to know what it is doing.


Corporations-Voting Trusts-Public Policy Jan 1936

Corporations-Voting Trusts-Public Policy

Michigan Law Review

Owning practically all the stock in two corporations, the decedent by will divided his holdings equally among his six children. To perpetuate the control of two sons who had been in active management for ten or twelve years, the other children transferred their stock in trust to the two sons to hold during the lives of these two or the life of the survivor, to vote, and to collect and pay over dividends. In an action by beneficiaries representing one-third of the stock to have the trust instruments declared void, the court held that the trust was not against public …


Corporate Reorganization Under Section 77b Of The Bankruptcy Act, Jacob J. Kaplan Nov 1934

Corporate Reorganization Under Section 77b Of The Bankruptcy Act, Jacob J. Kaplan

Michigan Law Review

In the closing hours of its legislative life the 73rd Congress adopted the amendment to the Bankruptcy Act providing for the reorganization of corporations, and designated as Section 77B. The Act was approved. by the President on June 7, 1934. The statute had had a long and checkered history in Congress. Such legislation barely failed of enactment in the preceding session when Congress first gave to natural persons availing themselves of bankruptcy procedure the right to call themselves "debtors" rather than "bankrupts," and provided a substantially similar method of reorganization for railroad corporations engaged in interstate commerce. The present statute …


Bankruptcy - Disposition Of Surplus Assets Jan 1934

Bankruptcy - Disposition Of Surplus Assets

Michigan Law Review

The Virginia Oil & Refining Co., a Delaware corporation with all of its business in Texas, went into bankruptcy in 1923. In 1931 hitherto worthless property became valuable and it appeared that there would be a large surplus after all of the creditors were paid. Various receivers in both the state and federal courts of Delaware and Texas, representing groups claiming to be stockholders of the company (which had forfeited its charter) and others claiming to represent the company, sought control of the assets. The bankruptcy court appointed a receiver, to whom the trustee was to turn over the surplus, …


Public Officers - When Do They Owe A Duty To A Particular Individual Rather Than A Class? Mar 1932

Public Officers - When Do They Owe A Duty To A Particular Individual Rather Than A Class?

Michigan Law Review

The plaintiff, a stockholder in the Bank of the United States, sued the defendant, superintendent of banks for New York State, for losses sustained when the bank failed as a result of the defendant's failure to perform certain acts required by statute. Held, the defendant, being charged by statute with a duty to all the people of the state, owed no duty to the stockholders as individuals, and was not liable to the plaintiff. Walker v. Broderick, 252 N. Y. S. 559 (1931).


Exchange Of Stock For Capitalized Profits, H. S. Richards May 1906

Exchange Of Stock For Capitalized Profits, H. S. Richards

Michigan Law Review

The judgment of Vice Chancellor Pitney in the somewhat recent case of See v. Heppenheimer is of more than usual importance on account of the nature of the interests involved, and the advanced position taken on the perplexing question of watered stock. Extensive notes on the case have appeared in legal periodicals, yet it would seem, in view of the doctrines announced, that more extensive comment will be profitable. The particular case is one of a series of suits growing out of the failure of the so-called "Straw Board Trust." In this particular case, See, as receiver of the Columbia …