Law Commons^™

The Shallows Where Federal Reserved Water Rights Founder: State Court Derogation Of The Winters Doctrine, Sandi Zellmer, Justin Huber

Sandi Zellmer

The doctrine of implied federally reserved water rights, as established by Winters v. U.S., 207 U.S. 564 (1908), is important to the realization of federal land management goals. Recently, the doctrine’s ability to protect those goals when federal land is set aside for non-Indian purposes has been greatly limited by several poorly reasoned and result-oriented state court decisions. The primary factors that have led to these erosions of the Winters doctrine’s utility are: (1) the McCarran Amendment, 43 U.S.C. § 666, which allows states to force the U.S. to assert its federally reserved water rights claims in state court general …