Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Articles 1 - 2 of 2
Full-Text Articles in Law
The Reenactment And Inaction Doctrines In State Tax Litigation, Steve R. Johnson
The Reenactment And Inaction Doctrines In State Tax Litigation, Steve R. Johnson
Scholarly Publications
This installment of Interpretation Matters discusses two related canons of statutory interpretation and illustrates their use in state and local tax controversies. Assume that a state revenue agency or court construes a tax statute and that the construction is later challenged in another case. Between the two cases, the state legislature reenacts the provision without changing it or the legislature takes no action to amend the provision to overturn the construction in the first case. Some courts treat the reenactment without change, or even the inaction, as evidence that the legislature agreed with the construction in the first case, so …
Substance And Form In State Taxation, Steve R. Johnson
Substance And Form In State Taxation, Steve R. Johnson
Scholarly Publications
In the interpretation of tax statutes, a venerable principle is that “taxation should move in an atmosphere of practical realities rather than amid the intricate and wooden concepts” of legal formalities. That principle is familiar in federal taxation, and it holds no less sway in state and local taxation. Indeed, the idea that the substance of a transaction usually controls over the form of the transaction is not confined to taxation; it is a principle of U.S. law generally.
The principle commands that the underlying reality of the events usually determines tax consequence; the forms or labels attached to the …