Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Law Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Articles 1 - 25 of 25

Full-Text Articles in Law

Recent Decisions, Michigan Law Review Dec 1942

Recent Decisions, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

The recent decisions consist merely of summaries of the facts and holdings of recent cases and are distinguished from the notes by the absence of discussion.


Recent Decisions, Michigan Law Review Oct 1942

Recent Decisions, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

The abstracts consist merely of summaries of the facts and holdings of recent cases and are distinguished from the notes by the absence of discussion.


Multiple Taxation Of Intangibles Aug 1942

Multiple Taxation Of Intangibles

Indiana Law Journal

Notes and Comments: Taxation


Criminal Law And Procedure - Statutes-Constitutionality Of Criminal Penalties For Unreasonable Deductions Under Federal Income Tax Statute, William H. Shipley Aug 1942

Criminal Law And Procedure - Statutes-Constitutionality Of Criminal Penalties For Unreasonable Deductions Under Federal Income Tax Statute, William H. Shipley

Michigan Law Review

Defendant was indicted for attempting to evade the federal tax on the income of a certain corporation for the years 1933 to 1936. In providing for deductions from gross income, the statute permits a reasonable allowance for salaries or other compensation for personal services. The government charged that the defendant was a party to a fraudulent scheme whereby, under the guise of paying commissions for services, which commissions were · deducted from gross income, the corporation distributed profits to its stockholders. The trial court submitted to the jury the issue whether the deduction represented a reasonable allowance for the services …


Executors And Administrators - Double Domicile - Inheritance Taxation Of Intangibles, Robert Walsh Aug 1942

Executors And Administrators - Double Domicile - Inheritance Taxation Of Intangibles, Robert Walsh

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff was appointed executor by a Georgia court which found that decedent had been domiciled in Georgia. Defendant was appointed administrator by a New York court which found that decedent was domiciled in New York. Plaintiff and defendant were interpleaded in the Delaware court by a Delaware corporation to determine who was entitled to shares of stock owned by decedent in the Delaware corporation. Plaintiff claimed that the Delaware court was required to give full faith and credit to the Georgia finding that decedent was domiciled in Georgia. The Supreme Court of Delaware found that decedent was domiciled in New …


Taxation - Federal Estate Taxation Of Life Insurance Effect Of Treasury Decision 5032 Amending Articles 25 And 27 Of The Estate Tax Regulations, Lloyd M. Forster Jun 1942

Taxation - Federal Estate Taxation Of Life Insurance Effect Of Treasury Decision 5032 Amending Articles 25 And 27 Of The Estate Tax Regulations, Lloyd M. Forster

Michigan Law Review

Stated briefly, the effect of T. D. 5032 has thus been to revert to the original test of payment of premiums for determining when insurance has been "taken out" by the decedent, and to abandon ownership of the policy as a basis for including the proceeds in decedent's estate, thereby departing from the fundamental theory of estate taxation. Thus the regulations, in closing one door to tax avoidance, apparently open another. While this avenue of escape may be narrowed by judicial interpretation, a change in the regulations probably will be required to seal it completely.


Constitutional Law - Due Process - Jurisdiction Of A State To Tax The Exercise Of A Power Of Appointment, Charles J. O'Laughlin Jun 1942

Constitutional Law - Due Process - Jurisdiction Of A State To Tax The Exercise Of A Power Of Appointment, Charles J. O'Laughlin

Michigan Law Review

Decedent's father, a resident of Massachusetts, by his last will created a trust of the residue of his estate, consisting of intangibles, and gave one share to decedent for life, with remainder to whomsoever decedent should appoint by will. The trust was administered in Massachusetts and there was no question as to that state's power to tax. Decedent, a resident of New York, appointed his share to his widow. The New York courts held that although the interest of the decedent fell within the provisions of the New York tax law imposing a tax upon the transfer of the net …


Taxation - Excise Taxes - Meaning Of Dues Or Membership Fees Under The Fereral Revenue Acts, William H. Shipley Jun 1942

Taxation - Excise Taxes - Meaning Of Dues Or Membership Fees Under The Fereral Revenue Acts, William H. Shipley

Michigan Law Review

The Winchester Country Club's by-laws provided for "annual dues" of fifty dollars which entitled the member to all the privileges of the club except golf. By paying fifty dollars more for "full privileges," members obtained the privilege of playing golf for a year. The club's practice was to bill members annually in advance, measured by the privileges previously held. If after such billing a member indicated that he did not want the golf privilege, no attempt was made to collect the charge. The federal government collected taxes on payments to the club for golf privileges on the ground that the …


Taxation - Federal Income Tax - Constructive Receipt Of Income By Lessor Corporation When Rents Paid Directly To Lessor's Stockholders, William H. Shipley May 1942

Taxation - Federal Income Tax - Constructive Receipt Of Income By Lessor Corporation When Rents Paid Directly To Lessor's Stockholders, William H. Shipley

Michigan Law Review

In 1864 the Joliet and Chicago Railroad Company made a perpetual lease without a defeasance clause of all of its property to another railroad company. Under the state law, the lease was a conveyance in fee. The lessee agreed to pay as rental an annual dividend of seven dollars a share on the then outstanding stock of the lessor, these payments to be made directly to the shareholders. The dividends paid by the lessee for the years 1931 to 1934 were taxed as income to the lessor, who now sues to recover the tax. Held, payments to the lessor's …


Taxation Of Annuity Contracts Under Federal Income Tax, Robert Meisenholder May 1942

Taxation Of Annuity Contracts Under Federal Income Tax, Robert Meisenholder

Michigan Law Review

A number of questions dealing with the taxability of commercial annuity policies under death tax statutes have received judicial consideration. By contrast, only a few questions dealing with the taxability of these contracts under income tax laws have been raised before the courts. But the income tax problems are equally important in terms of tax liability. Moreover, they will in the future assume an even larger significance in view of the large number of annuity contracts of various types which have been issued and are now being offered by insurance companies. Accordingly some explanation of these problems is warranted.


The Present Status Of Multiple Taxation Of Intangible Property, Robert C. Brown Apr 1942

The Present Status Of Multiple Taxation Of Intangible Property, Robert C. Brown

Michigan Law Review

The decision by the Supreme Court in 1932 of the case of First National Bank of Boston v. Maine represented the culmination of a fairly brief but apparently decisive effort by that Court substantially to do away with the taxation of intangible property by more than one state. Successive decisions within the three years previous had sought to do away with such taxation of debts ( no matter how evidenced) by more than one state; and First National Bank v. Maine laid down the same rule for corporate stock.


Federal Estate And Gift Taxation: A Review, Paul G. Kauper Apr 1942

Federal Estate And Gift Taxation: A Review, Paul G. Kauper

Michigan Law Review

Today's tax-encumbered citizen is not only aware that death and taxes are certain but also realizes that they walk hand-in-hand. At the most he may experience a sense of nostalgic grief over Pliny the Younger's argument that an inheritance tax "is an 'unnatural' tax, since it augments the grief and sorrow of the bereaved." He knows that as a matter of history Pliny's argument, however touching and delicate, has not deterred ways and means committees, intent on meeting revenue needs.


Taxation - Income Tax - Exemption Of Proceeds Of Insurance Policies Payable In The Form Of An Annuity, Wilbur Jacobs Mar 1942

Taxation - Income Tax - Exemption Of Proceeds Of Insurance Policies Payable In The Form Of An Annuity, Wilbur Jacobs

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff was the beneficiary of a life insurance policy payable in equal installments over a period of twenty years. The deferred payments had been substituted for payment of the face amount of the policy through an option in the policy exercised by the insured a short time before his death. The Commissioner of Internal Revenue included in gross income the amount by which each payment exceeded one-twentieth of the face amount of the policy on the theory that this excess was interest and hence not within the statute exempting insurance from gross income. Plaintiff sued to recover the tax paid. …


Taxation Of Partnership Assets Received By A Deceased Partner And His Estate, Donald H. Treadwell Mar 1942

Taxation Of Partnership Assets Received By A Deceased Partner And His Estate, Donald H. Treadwell

Michigan Law Review

The raising of funds to pay taxes will probably be a major problem of business men for many years to come. Closely rivaling it, however, is the problem of computing the tax. Though the economic definitions of income may be relatively simple, the complex business relationships necessitating equally complex accounting procedures often make the computation of income extremely difficult. This was demonstrated in the recent case of Helvering v. Enright's Estate, a tax case arising out of the death of a law partner. At the time of his death there were three types of assets which had been acquired …


Taxation - Income Tax - A Fixed Investment Trust As A Taxable Association, Harry M. Nayer Mar 1942

Taxation - Income Tax - A Fixed Investment Trust As A Taxable Association, Harry M. Nayer

Michigan Law Review

Bonds of a prescribed kind were deposited in an investment trust with defendant, who issued certificates representing equal undivided interests in the trust corpus. Additional interests were created by the deposit of eligible bonds and sufficient cash to make up the current value of an interest, and all such bonds and cash were commingled. The depositor was not confined in making up the new units to the same kinds of bonds that were used in the original units, but could vary them in his discretion. The depositor could order the elimination of unsound bonds by sale, and the proceeds of …


Taxation-- Use Tax--Collection By A Foreign Corporation--Inapplicable Where Foreign Corporation Makes Strictly Interstate Sales, Michigan Law Review Mar 1942

Taxation-- Use Tax--Collection By A Foreign Corporation--Inapplicable Where Foreign Corporation Makes Strictly Interstate Sales, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

The Michigan Use Tax Act requires every seller of tangible personal property for storage, use or other consumption in the state of Michigan, engaged in the business of selling at retail in Michigan, to collect the tax imposed by the act. Plaintiff is an Illinois corporation operating a merchant tailoring establishment in Chicago. It takes orders in Michigan, from residents, for clothes, fills the orders in Chicago and, by agreement, the title to the clothes is vested in the purchaser upon delivery in Chicago to an interstate carrier. It maintains a branch office in Detroit where samples are kept, salesmen …


United States - Contracts - Effect, When Tax Is Declared Unconstitutional, Of Provisions For Increase Or Decrease Of Purchase Price For Taxes "Imposed" Or "Changed", Wilbur Jacobs Mar 1942

United States - Contracts - Effect, When Tax Is Declared Unconstitutional, Of Provisions For Increase Or Decrease Of Purchase Price For Taxes "Imposed" Or "Changed", Wilbur Jacobs

Michigan Law Review

Between May 1935 and January 1936 the federal government purchased flour from respondent through contracts which contained a so-called "up and down" tax clause. The basic price charged included the A.A.A. processing taxes. During this same period respondent obtained an injunction against the collection of said processing taxes and, as a result of the decision of the Supreme Court in United States v. Butler, was relieved of liability for the tax. In a later suit brought by respondent in the Court of Claims to recover on other contracts, the government claimed a setoff for the amount of these taxes. …


Constitutional Law-Taxation - Express Immunity Of Federal Instrumentalities, Michigan Law Review Feb 1942

Constitutional Law-Taxation - Express Immunity Of Federal Instrumentalities, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

A federal land bank filed a complaint against defendant lumber company and the tax commissioner seeking exemption from a state sales tax on purchases of lumber by the bank. The Supreme Court of North Dakota found the bank liable for the tax and on certiorari to the United States Supreme Court it was held, that the Federal Farm Loan Act conferred express immunity from the tax upon the bank and that such Congressional exemption was constitutional by virtue of the "necessary and proper" clause. Federal Land Bank of St. Paul v. Bismarck Lumber Co. (U.S. 1941) 62 S. Ct. …


Tax Definition Of Reorganization: Mergers And Consolidations, Hugh B. Kuder Jr. Feb 1942

Tax Definition Of Reorganization: Mergers And Consolidations, Hugh B. Kuder Jr.

Michigan Law Review

In connection with income taxation, some importance is attached to the difference between mergers and consolidations. The difference may be of import in deciding whether or not income has been realized. Too, when the resulting corporation files a return, it may be necessary to determine whether it is the product of a merger or of a consolidation.


Payment Of Social Security Tax As Evidence Of Master-Servant Relationship, Charles V. Shipley Jan 1942

Payment Of Social Security Tax As Evidence Of Master-Servant Relationship, Charles V. Shipley

Kentucky Law Journal

No abstract provided.


Taxation - Insurance Companies - Considerations For Annuity Contracts As "Premiums'' Received For Insurance Contracts, Michigan Law Review Jan 1942

Taxation - Insurance Companies - Considerations For Annuity Contracts As "Premiums'' Received For Insurance Contracts, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

The defendant commissioner of insurance refused to issue to plaintiff insurance company a certificate of authority to do business in Kansas unless plaintiff paid back taxes claimed to be due on considerations received for "annuity contracts" by the plaintiff, in Kansas, between 1927 and 1938 inclusive. The tax in question was "upon all premiums" received during the year, but the plaintiff contended the word "premiums" did not include considerations received for "annuity contracts." Plaintiff brought mandamus to compel defendant commissioner to issue a certificate of authority to do business. Held, three judges dissenting, that the word "premiums" included considerations …


Book Review. Federal Taxation For The Lawyer By Houstin Shockey, Ritchie Gilruth Davis Jan 1942

Book Review. Federal Taxation For The Lawyer By Houstin Shockey, Ritchie Gilruth Davis

Articles by Maurer Faculty

No abstract provided.


Taxation - Income Tax - Capital Gains - Cost Basis To Distributee, David N. Mills Jan 1942

Taxation - Income Tax - Capital Gains - Cost Basis To Distributee, David N. Mills

Michigan Law Review

Testator died in 1903, and the executors turned over the residue of his estate to themselves as testamentary trustees in 1905. In 1923, pursuant to the will, trustees delivered part of the original trust property, together with other property purchased with trust funds, to plaintiff, the equitable remainderman under the trust. In 1930 plaintiff sold some of the securities which had constituted the corpus of the trust. In determining the cost basis for the capital gains tax on this transaction, plaintiff claimed that the market value on the date when the trustees delivered the property to him in 1923 should …


Taxation - Income Tax - Inclusion Of Unpaid Dividends In Decedent's Income, Michigan Law Review Jan 1942

Taxation - Income Tax - Inclusion Of Unpaid Dividends In Decedent's Income, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

Decedent owned stock in a corporation whose board of directors declared a dividend on April 30, 1934, for the fiscal year ending January 31, 1935, payable to stockholders of record at such times and in such installments as the directors might determine. At the time of decedent's death, October 15, 1934, only one-half of the dividend had been paid to him, but the commissioner included in the gross income of the decedent for the taxable period prior to death the entire amount of the dividend declared. The Board of Tax Appeals reduced this amount to the portion of the dividend …


Taxation - Power Of Municipality To Tax Income Of State Officials, Michigan Law Review Jan 1942

Taxation - Power Of Municipality To Tax Income Of State Officials, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

A Pennsylvania statute empowered the city of Philadelphia to levy taxes on "persons, transactions, occupations, privileges, subjects and personal property" within Philadelphia. Pursuant to such authority the city enacted an ordinance imposing a tax of one and one-half per cent annually on salaries, wages, commissions, and other compensation earned by nonresidents for work performed in Philadelphia. Plaintiff, employed by an agency of Pennsylvania engaged in performance of governmental functions, brought suit to restrain the collection of the tax. Held, the statute grants the power to tax salaries of state officials and is not invalidated by any doctrine of governmental …