Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Supreme Court of the United States
University of Cincinnati College of Law
Articles 1 - 1 of 1
Full-Text Articles in Law
Voluntary Dismissals, Jurisdiction & Waiving Appellate Review, Bryan Lammon
Voluntary Dismissals, Jurisdiction & Waiving Appellate Review, Bryan Lammon
University of Cincinnati Law Review
Litigants have long tried to manufacture a final, appealable decision by voluntarily dismissing their claims after an adverse interlocutory decision. Recently—and especially since the Supreme Court’s decision in Microsoft Corp. v. Baker—courts have thought that these dismissals created a jurisdictional problem. Either the voluntary dismissal did not produce a final decision, or the dismissal extinguished Article III jurisdiction. But the problem with these appeals is not jurisdictional. It’s waiver. A voluntary dismissal after an adverse interlocutory decision waives the right to appellate review. This Article shows the flaws in the jurisdictional rejection of this kind of manufactured finality and …