Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Articles 1 - 1 of 1
Full-Text Articles in Law
Substantial Guidance Without Substantive Guides: Resolving The Requirements Of Moore V. Texas And Hall V. Florida, Clinton M. Barker
Substantial Guidance Without Substantive Guides: Resolving The Requirements Of Moore V. Texas And Hall V. Florida, Clinton M. Barker
Vanderbilt Law Review
Exempting certain classes of people from the possibility of the death penalty is hardly new; Blackstone noted the common law prohibition on executing the insane, stating that "furiosus furore solum punitur"-madness is its own punishment.' Even then, however, "the reasons for the rule [were] less sure and less uniform than the rule itself." 2 In the United States, Eighth Amendment jurisprudence does little to clarify the reasons behind a particular death penalty exemption because it relies, in part, on the practice of the states to decide what is outside the bounds of acceptable punishment. 3 Because exemptions are thus dependent …