Law Commons^™

One Test To Rule Them All: Retiring The Dual Standard For Fictional Character Copyrightability In The Ninth Circuit, Kiersten Daly

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

From Captain Jack Sparrow sailing on the Black Pearl in Pirates of Caribbean to Frodo Baggins trekking through Mordor in Lord of the Rings, well-developed characters are vital to the success of a story. Iconic characters like Captain Jack and Frodo Baggins have each developed a cult following as a result of their interesting storylines and character development. The instant recognition and nostalgia associated with such iconic characters has motivated companies to monetize their likenesses. Whether it is car companies recreating the Batmobile or the recent trend in creating story-based pop-up shops, there is a lot of value …

A Potential Status Update For The Visual Artists Rights Act: The Role Of Social Media Response In Judicial Analysis Of Recognized Stature, Olivia Calamia

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

In 2020, visual artists used the power and reach of social media platforms to share works of art inspired by the Black Lives Matter movement, which experienced renewed vigor following the police murder of George Floyd on May 25, 2020. Many of these works have taken the form of murals painted on city streets, building faces, and other spaces that promote public viewing. Many artists hope that their works will endure long past this moment of social and political reckoning. Manhattan based artist Amir Diop expressed his wishes simply but eloquently: “My hope is that [my art] is a …

Protecting Fair Use From Algorithms, Internet Platforms, And The Copyright Office: A Critique Of The § 512 Study, Mary Kate Sherwood

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

In 1994, the Supreme Court of the United States held that a musical group’s parody of a well-known song could be fair use, which is a noninfringing use of copyrighted content. In 2006, the Second Circuit found that an artist’s use of copyrighted photographs in his own artwork constituted fair use. In 2016, the Ninth Circuit found that a video of a child dancing to a short clip of a copyrighted Prince song could be fair use. But in 2022, a creator who attempts to share her fair use of copyrighted material online may not have recourse to the …

Personal Foul: The Exploitation Of Ncaa Student-Athletes’ Publicity Rights, Jordan Pamlanye

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

In 2017, Donald De La Haye, a Division I football player for the University of Central Florida of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (“NCAA”), was deemed ineligible for NCAA participation due to his successful YouTube channel, “Deestroying.” De La Haye was a kicker for the University of Central Florida’s (“UCF”) football team. At the time, his YouTube channel had over 90,000 subscribers and almost 5,000,000 views. The NCAA found De La Haye ineligible because he was compensated for videos that included aspects of his life as an NCAA athlete—a violation of the NCAA bylaws.

The consequences of this decision …

The (Unnoticed) Revitalization Of The Doctrine Of Equivalents, Daryl Lim

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

Over the past century, few patent issues have been considered so often by the Supreme Court of the United States as the doctrine of equivalents (“DOE”). This judge-made rule deals with a question that lies at the heart of patent policy—what is the best way to define property rights in an invention? The doctrine gives patentees an opportunity to ensnare an accused device that does not literally infringe a patent claim if the accused device is substantially similar to each claim limitation. Patentees enjoy this advantage, but it comes at a cost to the public, who must face the …

Crises And Compulsory Licenses: Crafting A More Equitable Work-For-Hire Regime For Comic Book Creators, Ron Eniclerico

Journal of Civil Rights and Economic Development

(Excerpt)

The history of comic books is plagued by notable instances of creators being excluded from the market value of their work. This tradition dates back to the creation of Superman, a character who was so successful that his exploits essentially led to the development of the modern comic book industry. Superman’s creators, Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, sold the rights to the character to D.C. Comics in 1938 for a mere $130 before Superman ever appeared in print. Nobody at the time could have known how popular Superman would become or that a media empire would be built around …

So You Want To Be An Author: A Comparative Analysis Of The Authorial Rights Awarded To Performers, Daniel Gomez

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

In his classic 1980 song “On the Road Again,” Willie Nelson articulates that “the life [he] love[s] is making music with [his] friends.” This affinity for the life of a traveling performer likely has little to do with his authorial rights under the Copyright Act. However, as this Note demonstrates, Mr. Nelson indeed benefited from favorable authorial rights when compared to other types of performers, beyond the rights he acquired as the song’s writer. Specifically, the current law around the default authorial rights of performers provides greater protection to performers of sound recordings than it affords to visual and …

Nothing Is Inevitable: A Rejection Of The Inevitable Disclosure Doctrine Under The Defend Trade Secrets Act, Jacqueline R. Mancini

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

Until June 2013, Manish Desai worked for Molon Motor and Coil Corporation (“Molon”) as Head of Quality Control. In June of that year, Desai left Molon to take a position with a competitor of Molon, Nidec Motor Corporation (“Nidec”). Molon brought suit against Nidec for trade secret misappropriation and alleged that Desai copied confidential information onto a flash drive before his departure. Based on these allegations, Molon argued not only that Desai unlawfully disclosed its trade secrets but also that “Nidec used and continues to use that information.” Molon brought suit under the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act and …

Maximizing Intellectual Property: Optimality, Synchronicity, And Distributive Justice, David Blankfein-Tabachnick

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

This Article addresses the distributive structure of intellectual property and innovation policy and the foundational role it plays in distributive justice. Distributive accounts of law are undergoing a renaissance; an unprecedented paradigm shift away from the wealth-maximizing approach to law and legal theory and toward a distributive view. In line with this shift, this Article breaks new ground in providing a needed framework for a distributive theory of intellectual property law and innovation policy and articulates an appealing, egalitarian alternative to wealth- or welfare-maximizing accounts of intellectual property and innovation policy. In doing so, this Article diagnoses and serves …

Patently Inconsistent: State And Tribal Sovereign Immunity In Inter Partes Review, John Mixon

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

This Note is composed of four parts. Part I reviews the origins, development, and purpose of both tribal and state sovereign immunity, compares the two doctrines, and concludes that the two are functionally the same despite deriving from different historical roots. Part II provides an overview of the history and purpose behind the patent system, the America Invents Act, and IPRs. Part II also analyzes the constitutionality of IPRs, as decided by the Supreme Court in Oil States Energy Services, LLC v. Greene’s Energy Group, LLC. Part III introduces and addresses the five IPR decisions on state sovereign …

"The Song Is Ended But The Melody Lingers On": Protecting The Cultural History Of The Great American Songbook In The Face Of The Public Domain, Mollie Galchus

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

Part I of this Note discusses the history of American popular song from the late nineteenth century to the mid-twentieth century, showing how the music of the Great American Songbook is particularly monumental in that its sophistication and conglomeration of different musical influences created a unique American musical framework. Part II discusses the framework of music copyright law, including theories of music copyright law, the evolution of the length of music copyright terms in the United States, and the history of the CTEA. Part III argues that Congress should not extend the duration of music copyright now that the …

In Lieu Of Moral Rights For Ip-Wronged Music Vocalists: Personhood Theory, Moral Rights, And The Wppt Revisited, Tuneen E. Chisolm

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

The Introduction of this Article has identified some of the noneconomic harms of concern. Part I summarizes and compares copyright ownership, control, and existing protections for authors of music compositions and sound recordings under the Copyright Act. It also summarizes pertinent music industry practices that impact third party use of recorded vocalist performances. Part II provides a foundation for understanding the nature of legal protections for creative works and the philosophical underpinnings of copyright law and moral rights, comparing utilitarianism and natural rights theory to personhood theory. It also provides a brief explanation of moral rights. Part III looks …

If It Is Broken, You Should Not Fix It: The Threat Fair Repair Legislation Poses To The Manufacturer And The Consumer, Marissa Macaneney

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

This Note argues that fair repair legislation is not fair for manufacturers, and suggests that legislators look to a solution that has proved workable in an analogous context in the automobile repair industry. Part I outlines the history of the electronic device repair market and discusses the proposed state legislation. It concludes that federal copyright law is insufficient, current state proposals are flawed, and that a different solution is necessary. Part II will discuss alternate solutions in the automobile industry, legislation tailored to the agriculture industry, and recent concessions by a well-known manufacturer. Part III will propose a standardized …

New Wine, Old Wineskins: Application Of Intellectual Property Law To Web-Based Activity, Katherine G. Grincewich, Esq.

The Catholic Lawyer

No abstract provided.

Common Copyright Calamities, G. Franklin Rothwell, Esq.

The Catholic Lawyer

No abstract provided.

New Copyright Law And Its Implications, John A. Liekweg

The Catholic Lawyer

No abstract provided.

The Universal Destination Of Pharmaceutical Patents: Reflecting On Trips Through The Lens Of Aquinas, Sam Castree, Iii

Journal of Catholic Legal Studies

No abstract provided.

Copyrightability Of Leed-Certified Buildings: Approaching The Awcpa To Promote Green Architecture, Stephen Accursio Maniscalco

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

Part I of this Note discusses green architecture, the history and structure of the LEED certification system, and the history and structure of the AWCPA. Part II discusses the approaches courts have taken in applying the AWCPA. Finally, Part III explores ways that LEED may affect courts’ analyses. It explains why and how courts may deny copyright protection in many elements of LEED-certified architectural works. It then proposes a reading of the AWCPA that will provide appropriate copyright protection to green buildings that are original in design. This Note argues that courts should not consider green market demands, the …

The Costs Of Harmonization: The Embrace Of An International Copyright Regime In Golan V. Holder, Angelie Thomas

Journal of International and Comparative Law

No abstract provided.

Cutting Out The Middleman: Why "Look And Feel" Should Be Ignored In Trade Dress Law, Nicholas Dimarino

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

Part I of this Note discusses the background and elements of general trade dress law. Part II discusses the narrower issue of "look and feel" in the context of websites and outlines how courts have currently addressed the "look and feel" issue. Part III proposes that courts ignore the artificial "look and feel" distinction and instead apply normal trade dress analyses and elements. This solution, which requires that courts adhere to a workable standard that serves the underlying purpose of trade dress law, allows recognition of the distinctive characteristics of website trade dress claims, while reducing the risk of …

Protecting American Innovators By Combating The Decline Of Patents Granted To Small Entities, W. Keith Robinson

St. John's Law Review

(Excerpt)

Part I of this Article discusses the current state of the U.S. patent system and reviews some of the challenges entrepreneurs and small entities face regarding patenting their inventions. Part II reviews some patent reform proposals and existing programs and discusses their impact on small entities. Part III highlights the current USPTO examination programs and discusses the effectiveness of the various programs. Part IV sets forth the proposed program, prioritizing a select number of patent applications where the inventor is an entrepreneur or small entity. The Article concludes in Part V, which suggests how patent stakeholders, including the USPTO, …