Law Commons^™

Thinking Outside The Box: Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis, In Vitro Fertilization, And Disability Screening In The Wake Of Box V. Planned Parenthood, Christian J. Sorensen

William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal

A circuit split has recently emerged regarding the constitutionality of state laws banning trait-selective abortions, i.e., abortions based on fetal characteristics like disability. Much of the dialogue surrounding trait selection has revolved around whether such abortions are eugenic in nature and whether they could be regulated differently than other forms of abortion—under either Roe and Casey or the post- Roe regime ushered in by Dobbs. However, the same concerns underlying this debate over eugenic abortions apply with equal force to preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) coupled with in vitro fertilization. Because PGD seems certain to be the next battlefield in …