Digital Commons Network^™

Legal Construct Validation: Expanding Empirical Legal Scholarship To Unobservable Concepts, David S. Goldman

David S Goldman

This article proposes a system with which to empirically study unobservable legal concepts. Although empirical legal scholarship is becoming an increasingly important component of legal studies, its usefulness has so far been confined to topics that are directly observable, such as court decisions or crime rates. This limitation has unfortunately prevented the study of many of law’s foundational concepts, such as deterrence, incentives, or freedom, because they are not directly measurable. But this obstacle can be overcome by looking to social sciences, particularly psychology, that have developed mechanisms for assessing concepts like happiness or depression that cannot be directly measured. …

Federally Mandated Informed Consent: Has Government Gone Too Far?, Linda P. Mckenzie

Linda P. McKenzie

In 2003, President George W. Bush signed legislation targeted at preventing what lawmakers said was a single, specific abortion procedure. The bill banned a method that is known outside of the medical community as "partial birth abortion." Lower courts, however, struck down the law as a violation of the Supreme Court's requirement that state limits on abortion must include an exception for the life or health of the pregnant woman. The lower courts were upheld by the three circuit courts who reviewed the Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003. The U.S. Supreme Court accepted certiorari and recently heard oral …

The Geography Of Climate Change Litigation Part 2: Narratives Of Nation-States And Thirdspace, Hari M. Osofsky

Hari Osofsky

This article aims to interweave two current crises for law and policy in the United States: (1) the extent of our commitment to international law and (2) the approach we will take to regulating global climate change. It argues that achieving progress on both fronts requires interrogating the geographic assumptions in major conceptual approaches to international legal theory and the implications of those assumptions for their narratives of climate change litigation. To that end, it develops a taxonomy of international legal theory based on how those approaches view nation-state spaces—Westphalian, modified Westphalian, pluralist, and critical—and considers how a law and …

Of Marriage And Monarchy: Why John Locke Would Support Same-Sex Marriage, William B. Turner

William B Turner

Arguments about discrimination based on sexual orientation generally rest on interpretations of the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment or about rights to autonomy rooted in modern substantive due process doctrine. Such theories typically presuppose a government that remains neutral among competing moral claims. This Article, by contrast, develops an account of rights against sexual orientation discrimination—including recognition of same-sex marriage—that does not depend on a thin moral conception of the liberal state. Instead, I situate lesbian/gay rights within a Lockean political theory of consent. John Locke’s theory of government, which was highly influential for the Founders of the …

Effective Implementation Of The Trafficking Of Persons And Involuntary Servitude Articles: Lessons From The Criminal Justice System Response To The Illinois Domestic Violence Act, Alison L. Stankus, Jennifer A. Kuhn

Alison L Stankus

When the Illinois Domestic Violence Act was enacted in 1986, the General Assembly acknowledged that “the legal system has ineffectively dealt with family violence in the past … and has not adequately acknowledged the criminal nature of domestic violence; that, although many laws have changed, in practice there is still widespread failure to appropriately protect and assist victims.” However, despite these stated purposes, the criminal justice system response to the Act in the last twenty years has been slow to correct this failure. Last year, the Trafficking of Persons and Involuntary Servitude Articles were added to the Illinois Criminal Code. …

Housing Policy In The People's Republic Of China: Successes And Disappointments, Joyce Palomar, Jianbo Lou

Joyce Palomar

ABSTRACT: This paper is written and submitted by Peking University (Beijing University) Center for Real Estate Law, Director, Prof. Lou Jianbo, and Assistant Director, Prof. Joyce Palomar, authors. The paper examines the People's Republic of China's national approaches beginning in 1948 to the nation's urban housing crisis. The paper focuses on policy approaches and strategies for activating the private sector as a means to improve housing conditions. It presents recent statistical results of the application of housing as a leading economic development sector.

"Legal Traditions" And International Commercial Arbitration, Leon E. Trakman

Leon E Trakman Dean

The Common and Civil Law traditions underpin international commercial arbitration. From the doctrine of freedom of contract to the procedures governing arbitral hearings, international arbitration has built its legal culture around these two great traditions. Recent concerns expressed by luminaries like William Slate, President of the American Arbitration Association, challenge the pervasive influence of these legal traditions over modern arbitration. Is the practice of law in the United States too litigious to serve as a viable model for international commercial arbitration? Is the culture of international arbitration unduly steeped in the Common and Civil Law at the expense of other …

The Legal Foundation Of Cost-Benefit Analysis, Richard O. Zerbe

Richard O Zerbe Jr.

The foundations of cost-benefit analysis (CBA) are legal, and this understanding provides a different view of it. This paper proposes to provide a fully realized foundation for CBA. Such a foundation rests on legal rights and also amends the failure of CBA to include moral sentiments, which arose in the attempt to avoid interpersonal comparisons. This amended legal foundation largely vitiates the extreme positions that have come to dominate thinking about CBA. CBA is increasingly questioned in the legal literature, even as it is being promoted by government practice and the economics literature, and the positions that have arisen from …

The Military Abortion Ban: How 10 U.S.C. Section 1093 Violates International Standards Of Reproductive Healthcare, Sabrina E. Dunlap

Sabrina E Dunlap

Under 10 U.S.C. Section 1093, women in the military cannot obtain abortion services in military hospitals even if they use their own funds. Women who are stationed abroad are forced to search for services elsewhere in the foreign country in which they are stationed, facing cultural barriers, language barriers, difficult travel arrangements and high costs. In the last ten years, clear standards of reproductive health emerged at an international level, with women’s health being the center of the International Conference on Population and Development, and the Fourth World Conference on Women, among others. The United States is simultaneously encouraging developing …

The Fair Track To Expanded Free Trade: Making Taa Benefits More Accessible To American Workers, William J. Mateikis

William J. Mateikis

If Congress again wants to use the TAA program in a bargain for Fast Track authority … then DOL must fix its broken certification process and Congress should amend the TAA Act to reduce worker resistance to expanded free trade. The topic is quite timely given the expiration of fast track (trade promotion) authority on June 30, 2007 and reauthorization of the TAA program due October 1, 2007. The paper has five parts. Following the Introduction, Part II of the paper outlines the politics of U.S. trade liberalization since the mid-1930s and shows that, at times over the past three …

Gender Matters: Making The Case For Trans Inclusion, Nancy J. Knauer

Nancy J. Knauer

Gender Matters: Making the Case for Trans Inclusion Nancy J. Knauer, Peter J. Liacouras Professor of Law Beasley School of Law, Temple University ABSTRACT The transgender communities are producing an important and nuanced critique of our gender system. For community members, the project is self-constitutive and, therefore, has an immediacy that also marks the efforts of other marginalized groups who have attempted to make sense of the world through description, interrogation, and, ultimately, a program for transformation. The transgender project also has universalizing elements because, existing within the gender system, each one of us embodies a particular gender articulation. It …

Property And Radically Changed Circumstances, John Lovett

John Lovett

Although Hurricane Katrina altered our national dialogue about many issues, few scholars have addressed whether the storm changed thinking about fundamental property relationships. This article fills that void in two ways. First, it creates a theoretical framework for understanding property law in the context of events producing radically changed circumstances. It does this by defining these events, exploring the mismatch between property law’s traditional focus on stability and environments of radical change, creating a taxonomy of property relationships tailored for this exploration, describing typical problems confronted after an event of radical change, and finally developing a set of normative criteria …

New Governance, Compliance, And Principles-Based Securities Regulation, Cristie L. Ford

Cristie L. Ford

The UK securities regulator, the Financial Services Authority, claims that its "principles-based" approach to securities regulation is simply "better" than what it characterizes as the prescriptive, rules-based American approach. The striking shift in financial sector business from New York to London over the last two years has brought the question of the wisdom of principles-based regulation into sharp relief. In fact, an FSA-style regulatory approach may also be taking hold in Canada, through the agency of the province of British Columbia. This paper examines BC's innovative proposals for a principles-based securities regime through the lens of New Governance theory. I …

Who Decides? A Comparative Institutional Approach To International Trade Law, Gregory C. Shaffer

Gregory C Shaffer

ABSTRACT: WHO DECIDES?

A COMPARATIVE INSTITUTIONAL APPROACH TO INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW

by Gregory Shaffer

Wing-Tat Lee Chair of International Law, Loyola University Chicago School of Law

This article has two core theses. First, as regards the issue of power in global governance, it maintains that meaningful policy choices need to be made from a comparative institutional analytic perspective since no governance mechanism provides for completely unbiased participation or representation of affected interests. All institutions are imperfect. Resource asymmetries are always present. Thus, while it is important to examine the role of power in global governance, a risk of choosing power …

Child Laundering As Exploitation: Applying Anti-Trafficking Norms To Intercountry Adoption Under The Coming Hague Regime, David M. Smolin

David M. Smolin

Child laundering occurs when children are illicitly obtained by fraud, force, or funds, and then processed through false paperwork into "orphans" and then adoptees. Child laundering thus involves illegally obtaining children by abduction or purchase for purposes of adoption. My prior work has documented and analyzed the widespread existence of child laundering in the intercountry adoption system. This article argues that child laundering is a form of exploitation, and hence qualifies as a form of human trafficking. Once child laundering is understood as an exploitative form of child trafficking, legal and ethical norms currently applied to human trafficking become applicable. …

'Scrubbing' The Inbox: A Constitutional Alternative To Child Protection Registries, David Logan Pool

David Logan Pool

After the judicial demise of the Communications Decency Act and Child Online Protection Act and the continued impotency of CAN-SPAM to curb unsolicited commercial email, children remain vulnerable to harmful, indecent content via their inbox. In a recent attempt to curtail such exposure, several States have created Child Protection Registries. In essence, the laws allow children to register their email addresses with the state. The state laws impose significant criminal and civil penalties on senders of indecent material who send such emails to registered minors. Because the States retain the list of protected emails, senders of potentially indecent emails must, …

Entrapment And Terrorism, Dru Stevenson

Dru Stevenson

The thesis of this article is that the unique nature of terrorist crime requires a tweaking of the entrapment rules. The entrapment defense is our legal system’s primary mechanism for regulating government sting operations. I argue that sting operations and surveillance are conceptually distinct (or rival) methods of law enforcement, which compete for resource allocation. If an enforcement agency favors one method, it shifts resources away from the other. To the extent that we dislike panoptic government surveillance, we can steer enforcement agencies away from it by encouraging targeted stings; and we can achieve this, in part, by adapting the …