Law Commons^™

Case-By-Case Adjudication And The Path Of The Law, Anthony Niblett

Anthony Niblett

How can a centrist president or governor best influence law through the appointment of judges? Imagine that there are two sitting judges and one of the positions becomes vacant. The other, veteran judge is on the extreme right, from the perspective of the executive, and the executive prefers centrist outcomes. Should the executive appoint a centrist or, instead, appoint a left-wing extremist who might offset the sitting, right-wing judge? Conventional wisdom holds that judges counteract, or balance, one another; that is, a left-wing appointment carries the best hope offsetting the existing, right-wing judge. Following this intuition, a moderate appointment would …