Law Commons^™

Cleaning Up Bankruptcy: Limiting The Dischargeability Of Environmental Cleanup Costs, Sonali P. Chitre

Sonali P Chitre

This article reconciles the joint aims of environmental and bankruptcy law after Judge Posner’s myopic opinion in the Seventh Circuit’s resolution of U.S. v. Apex Oil. These two areas of law represent alternative means to the same end—the equitable distribution of limited resources—and share equity’s traditional emphasis of function over form. Ignoring these principles, Judge Posner ruled in Apex that a cleanup order constitutes a dischargeable “claim” when styled as a legal judgment but not when styled as an equitable injunction. This despite the fact that in either case the liability amounts to the same thing-payment must be made for …

Cleaning Up Bankruptcy: Limiting The Dischargeability Of Environmental Cleanup Costs, Sonali P. Chitre

Sonali P Chitre

This article reconciles the joint aims of environmental and bankruptcy law after Judge Posner’s myopic opinion in the Seventh Circuit’s resolution of U.S. v. Apex Oil. These two areas of law represent alternative means to the same end—the equitable distribution of limited resources—and share equity’s traditional emphasis of function over form. Ignoring these principles, Judge Posner ruled in Apex that a cleanup order constitutes a dischargeable “claim” when styled as a legal judgment but not when styled as an equitable injunction. This despite the fact that in either case the liability amounts to the same thing-payment must be made for …

Interpreting The Supreme Court’S Treatment Of The Chrysler Bankruptcy And Its Impact On Future Business Reorganizations, Fred N. David

Fred David

On June 9, 2009, the Supreme Court terminated its stay of Chrysler’s sale of substantially all of the company’s assets to a new entity, dubbed “New Chrysler” with the backing of European automaker Fiat. The effect of that ruling was to permit the sale to close the next day and bring to an end a chaotic period that determined Chrysler’s future. However, critics of the sale to Fiat argued that the Supreme Court’s ruling would also have a detrimental effect on secured credit and undermined the creditor protections normally afforded by Chapter 11 going forward.

But the Supreme Court was …

Marriage And Law Reform: Lessons From The Nineteenth Century Michigan Married Women’S Property Acts, Ellen Dannin

Ellen Dannin

If law reform had the neat trajectory of a bullet from a smoking gun, life and law would be neater – but less interesting. This article began as a simple empirical study to test whether Michigan’s 1844 Married Women’s Property Act affected conveyancing.

When the results showed that it had no effect – that married women were included as grantors even before the MWPA made it legal for them to own property – the study expanded into a quest to identify the processes that led to its enactment and explained its operation on the family, a fundamental social institution. In …

The Conflicting Concerns Of The Automatic Stay And Environmental Laws, Brett T. Bradford

Brett T. Bradford

This paper explores the conflict between the automatic stay in bankruptcy law and environmental laws regarding cleaning up pollution. It is shown that the two areas of law have fundamentally different purposes that work to disrupt the bankruptcy process. The purpose of the automatic stay is seriously disrupted by the government imposing clean up costs on the debtor while in bankruptcy. This paper shows the affects of the two conflicting areas of law and possible solutions to the problem.

A Consequential Approach To Interpretation And Interpretive Risk: Rethinking Judicial Intervention From Contracts To The Chrysler Bankruptcy, J. P. Kostritsky

Juliet P Kostritsky

Abstract When contracts remain ambiguous or incomplete, courts and scholars must confront the inevitable question of when intervention in private contracts is justified. To deal with the unresolution or residual uncertainty, the Austrian economists and the new textualists suggest that any intervention would be a fool’s errand. Their position amounts to an unvarying posture that any party asking for an additional term or a broad interpretation will always lose. Recognizing that there is an interpretive risk in all contracts, the court should adopt an interpretive methodology that parties would be willing to adopt and that would enhance the willingness of …

Bankruptcy Reorganizations And The Troubling Legacy Of Chrysler And Gm, Ralph E. Brubaker, Charles J. Tabb

Ralph E. Brubaker

BANKRUPTCY REORGANIZATIONS AND THE

TROUBLING LEGACY OF CHRYSLER AND GM

Ralph Brubaker

University of Illinois College of Law

Charles Jordan Tabb

University of Illinois College of Law

Abstract:

The Chrysler and General Motors bankruptcy reorganizations represent the culmination of a sea-change in corporate restructuring practice that has occurred largely over the course of just the past decade. A bankruptcy reorganization has traditionally been effectuated though a chapter 11 plan of reorganization, with elaborate requirements for disclosure, creditor voting, and allocation of stakes in the reorganized debtor entity’s new capital structure among creditors and owners. Such an internal boot-strap reorganization, though, …

Bankruptcy Reorganizations And The Troubling Legacy Of Chrysler And Gm, Ralph E. Brubaker

Ralph E. Brubaker

BANKRUPTCY REORGANIZATIONS AND THE

TROUBLING LEGACY OF CHRYSLER AND GM

Ralph Brubaker

University of Illinois College of Law

Charles Jordan Tabb

University of Illinois College of Law

Abstract:

The Chrysler and General Motors bankruptcy reorganizations represent the culmination of a sea-change in corporate restructuring practice that has occurred largely over the course of just the past decade. A bankruptcy reorganization has traditionally been effectuated though a chapter 11 plan of reorganization, with elaborate requirements for disclosure, creditor voting, and allocation of stakes in the reorganized debtor entity’s new capital structure among creditors and owners. Such an internal boot-strap reorganization, though, …

The Roles Of Acceleration, David Hahn

David Hahn

Acceleration clauses are found in most debt instruments. Upon the occurrence of predetermined triggering event, acceleration makes a creditor's future claim due and payable. While debt covenants have been analyzed extensively in the academic literature, the role of acceleration has been overlooked. This paper examines the role of acceleration clauses and maintains that they play a critical role in debt financing. The paper argues that the prime role of acceleration is to perfect a complex set of governance mechanisms within the corporate setting. This governance role is comprised of three parts. First, acceleration is a complementary measure that supports debt …

The Case For "Cramdown": Eliminating The Practical And Ideological Barriers To Pure Mortgage Modification, Peter J. Leo

Peter J Leo

This article was prepared for a seminar in Consumer Protection. The article makes the case that Congress should modify the Bankruptcy Code to allow for judicial modification of home mortgages on a bankrupt’s principal residence as a means of combating the foreclosure crisis. The article examines two different proposals originally published in the Minnesota Law Review and the Yale Journal on Regulation, examines some of the deficiencies in those proposals, and concludes that “cramdown” will be a more effective means of keeping consumers in their homes.

Student Loans In Bankruptcy: The Undue Hardship Test Is An Unnecessary Burden, James M. Leiby

James M Leiby

No abstract provided.

Befuddlement Betwixt Two Fulcrums: Calibrating The Scales Of Justice To Ascertain Fraudulent Transfers In Leveraged Buyouts, John H. Ginsberg, M. Katie Burgess, Zachary R. Caldwell, Daniel R. Czerwonka

John H. Ginsberg

In a leveraged buyout, a company goes deep into debt and grants liens on its assets to finance the purchase of itself. The company’s risk of insolvency increases with its debt burden. Unsecured creditors of the company are exposed to insolvency risk without compensation, unlike the parties to the leveraged buyout—buyer, seller and lender—all of whom expect good returns on the lesser risks to which they are exposed. When a leveraged buyout leaves the acquired company with “unreasonably small capital” such that insolvency is “reasonably foreseeable” upon consummation of the buyout, unsecured creditors may have recourse to constructive-fraudulent-transfer law. They …

What Determines Professionals’ Bankruptcy Fees: An Empirical Investigation, Gijs Van Dijk, Martin Gramatikov

Martin Gramatikov

Countries have adopted different approaches to compensate bankruptcy trustees for winding up the estate. The approaches vary from state trustees to funding mechanisms where bankruptcy trustees receive a fixed fee, to a system where their fees depend on the size of the assets. Few studies have addressed the cost-effectiveness of the different approaches. This study contributes to this topic by examining the fees of the winding up, including an analysis of the determinants of these fees. After analyzing 289 Dutch bankruptcies consisting of short-term and medium-term cases, we find substantial differences in the mean hourly remuneration fees of bankruptcy trustees. …