Law Commons^™

Rethinking Peer Review: Detecting And Addressing Medical Malpractice Claims Risk, Ilene N. Moore, James W. Pichert, Gerald B. Hickson, Charles Federspiel, Jennifer U. Blackford

Vanderbilt Law Review

A medical center department chair has just been notified that a physician in his department, "Dr. G," is being sued for the fifth time in seven years. The CEO of co-defendant hospital wants the chair to solve Dr. G's "claims problems." At the chair's request, the hospital peer review committee evaluates Dr. G's malpractice cases. While committee members note some minor concerns in the cases, they conclude that in each circumstance he has met the standard of care. They cannot identify any specific technical or educational need, nor can they supply justification for a disciplinary action. The chair is in …