Law Commons^™

The Types Of Evidence: An Analysis, Lyman R. Patterson

Vanderbilt Law Review

Since the purpose of this article is to analyze evidence in functional terms, it may be helpful at the outset to state the basic ideas which underlie the discussion.

1. Evidence consists of propositions of fact which are related to another proposition, a proposed conclusion. Evidence is thus to be distinguished from the fact or facts which are its basis. 2. The essential relationship of propositions which are evidence to the proposition which is the proposed conclusion is relevancy. 3. The relevancy of evidence to the proposed conclusion is determined by the inference drawn from the evidence. If the evidence …

"Civilizing" Nonjury Trials, F. R. Lacy

Vanderbilt Law Review

This article is intended to make people think about American procedure, yet it is devoted largely to a description of Austrian and Israeli civil procedure and perhaps that calls for some disclaiming and confessing and avoiding. I have spent only a few months in the two countries and have no doubt that I am open to the charge, made against far more seasoned American comparatists, that I tend to look at foreign systems through American conceptual spectacles. By way of avoidance let me offer, first, the usual defense of the popularizer. There never will be many serious students of comparative …

Compensation For Victims Of Crimes, Law Review Staff

Vanderbilt Law Review

The steadily increasing number of crimes in the United States and other Western countries brings about not only the destruction of property and the expenditure of money and effort to apprehend and punish the criminals, but also physical injury to thousands of innocent victims.' Although our society has established elaborate safe-guards for the rights of the accused criminal, the injured victim is left to shoulder the responsibility of paying his own medical bills and providing for his own living expenses while he is unable to work. Because of the extremely high cost of medical and hospital care, even a well …

Municipal Industrial Development Bonds, Alfred E. Abbey

Vanderbilt Law Review

Several years ago a national business magazine carried an article styled "You Gotta Have A Golf Course."' The article outlined the efforts of a small town to attract new industry and the awkward realization by the city fathers that they were losing out to the competition because their community lacked such a recreational facility. After this finding, several public spirited citizens raised the necessary funds and constructed a nine-hole course. These efforts were soon rewarded when a large industrial concern located a new manufacturing plant in their city. Industrial development bonds are essentially intended to serve the same purpose as …

Recent Cases, Law Review Staff

Vanderbilt Law Review

Conflict of Laws--Mexican Bilateral Divorce Decree Recognized Even Though Neither Party was a Mexican Domiciliary At Time of Divorce

=============================

Constitutional Law--Section 504 of LMRDA a Bill of Attainder

=============================

Corporations--DeFacto Merger--Dissenters' Rights--Construction of Merger and Amendment Statutes

=============================

Criminal Law--Search and Seizure--Standing Granted for Dyer Act Prosecutions Without Allegation of Possession

=============================

Damages--Restitutionary Relief for Breach of Contract Granted Under the Tucker Act to a Government Contractor

=============================

Federal Employers' Liability Act--Applicability of "In Whole or in Part" Rule of Proximate Cause to Employer's Efforts To Prove Contributory Negligence Plaintiff brought suit under the Federal Employers' Liability Act'

============================= …

Condominium--Tax Aspects Of Ownership, Richard R. Mcdowell

Vanderbilt Law Review

The ancient concept of condominium ownership has been revived in this country as an answer to the increasing demand for adequate urban housing. The advantages of individual home ownership have had to be subordinated by many families in favor of the convenience of apartment rental. A partial answer to this problem has been found in the creation of cooperative apartments, but this device still leaves much to be desired.' It was not until Puerto Rico achieved its initial success with condominiums that the advantages of this form of home ownership fully came to the attention of this country. To encourage …

Enforcement Of Statutory Rights Of Employees Of Government Contractors, C. Thomas Cates

Vanderbilt Law Review

The United States government disburses a vast amount of money each year to meet its contractual obligations. As the size of the federal government and the dimension of the services it provides continue to expand, the importance of federal contract spending in our national economy is likely to reach staggering proportions.' Presently there are a great many manufacturing, construction, and brokerage concerns engaged in work on a large number of federal government contracts. The purpose of this note is to discuss in general the major federal statutes which govern rights of employees of those performing government contracts and to discuss …

Managerial Problems Of The Enterprise, Douglas C. Basil

Vanderbilt Law Review

The small firm, particularly the newly formed one, is confronted with problems ranging from the shortage of capital to the legal intricacies of organizational form. The technical obstacle of raising capital, obtaining sales outlets, and purchasing equipment must be surmounted. In the final analysis, however, the success of a small business depends upon the managerial ability of its owner.' The purpose of this article is to identify a few of the major management problems of the small enterprise and suggest appropriate solutions. One continuous difficulty is the structuring of the organization. At what point should staff specialization occur? What are …

Small Business Growth And Survival During The First Two Years, Kurt B. Mayer, Sidney Goldstein

Vanderbilt Law Review

In summary, analysis of the businesses observed in this study reveals that certain conditions are more likely to have fatal effects on a business venture than others. Undercapitalization, managerial in-competence, and personality defects appear to be insurmountable liabilities which cannot be mitigated by the presence of the other assets. Although adequate capital and managerial competence are indispensable for survival, they are rarely sufficient in themselves to insure it. They must be supplemented by other factors, such as motivation, hard work, persistence, and flexibility.

Condominium: A Reconciliation Of Competing Interests?, James C. Clark

Vanderbilt Law Review

This note will first examine some of the operative provisions of the condominium statutes. Particular emphasis will be placed upon those provisions which are basic to the creation, existence, and dissolution of this unique form of property ownership. The FHA Model Statute For Creation of Apartment Ownership will be the principal vehicle of analysis, for it is the basis of many of the state condominium statutes. State provisions which differ from the Model Act will then be examined to discover the best statutory answer to the needs of condominium housing. Finally, attention will be focused on the tax implications of …

Judicial Notice Of Foreign Law, Jerome J. Krasa

Vanderbilt Law Review

A fundamental cleavage exists between the two methods of viewing judicial notice. Both views must be understood before the doctrine of judicial notice can be said to have a real meaning applicable to the whole variety of legal problems which arise today. This understanding must be achieved before many of the seeming inconsistencies in what has been written about the doctrine can be clarified. Finally, this basic understanding must be had if any comprehension of the operation of judicial notice in any specific field of law is possible.

Charitable Tort Immunity Under The First Amendment, I. Stephen North

Vanderbilt Law Review

The doctrine of charitable tort immunity was conceived in England in 1861. The case of Holliday v. Leonard' held that to apply funds in trust to satisfy a tort claim would be to thwart the intent of the donor. In 1871, Holliday was overruled and since then charities in England have been liable for their torts. Apparently unaware that the Holliday case had been overruled, the courts of Massachusetts and Maryland' cited it as authority and established the immunity rule in America. From the beginning, the doctrine was not without its dissenters. In 1879, for example, Rhode Island rejected immunity. …

Recent Cases, Law Review Staff

Vanderbilt Law Review

Advertising--Undisclosed Use of Simulations In Television Commercials--a Deceptive Practice

==============================

Antitrust Law--News Service Package Contract, a Tying Arrangement under Section I of the Sherman Act

==============================

Antitrust--Union-Employer Agreements as to Labor Demands To Be Sought From Other Employers

==============================

Constitutional Law--Laws Prohibiting the Use of Contraceptives by Married Couples for the Prevention of Conception Are Unconstitutional

==============================

Constitutional Law--Rights of Addressee To Receive "Communist Political Propaganda" Protected Under First Amendment

==============================

Federal Courts--Erie Doctrine Not the Test for Applicability of Federal Rules of Civil Procedure

==============================

Constitutional Law--Televising of Criminal Trials Held Violative of the Right to a Fair Trial …

Obscene Literature, Law Review Staff

Vanderbilt Law Review

Obscene Literature

In 1959 the United States Supreme Court in Smith v. California'held a city and county ordinance unconstitutional for failure to require scienter on the part of a defendant. That ordinance, like many other ordinances and state statutes, subjected a bookseller to criminal prosecution for the sale of obscene literature regardless of whether he knew that it was obscene. The Court reasoned that such an ordinance would result in a bookseller's refusal to sell many publications which would not be legally suppressible but which the seller suspected of being obscene, perhaps without having read them. This self-censorship would constitute …

When Will The Corporate Form Save Taxes?, Richard L. Strecker

Vanderbilt Law Review

While major emphasis will be placed upon the tax considerations involved in answering the question posed by the title, the broader problem is aptly stated in the familiar phrase, "Choice of Business Form."' It is not possible to consider this problem realistically without taking into account the context of the business and private law considerations which must enter into the decision, and may indeed be controlling over the tax factors. Therefore, the question, "When Will the Corporate Form Save Taxes?" will be discussed in the light of the full legal and business milieu.

Financing -- A Major Problem Of Small Business, Joseph T. Howell Jr.

Vanderbilt Law Review

It is imperative that a definitive study of small business include a discourse on financing.' Generally, the first consideration of a prospective entrepreneur is the availability of sufficient capital, borrowed or paid-in, to support the activity of his business. Of paramount importance, however, to those who attempt to assess the prospects of survival and future growth of a company is the recognition that all considerations are secondary to the human factor. The careful banker, while requiring collateral to secure a loan, depends on his estimation of the applicant's personality traits. While the adequacy of capital contributes to the success of …

Right Of First Refusal--Homogeniety In The Condominium, Ira E. Parker, Iii

Vanderbilt Law Review

The condominium, a newly popular but relatively old' concept in real property law, is defined basically as an apartment project involving individual fee ownership of a family unit in a multi-unit structure or structures. To complete the ownership picture, the individual fee owners are also tenants in common, with undivided interests, in the land on which the structure is built, and in other parts of the structure which are not part of an individual unit. Due to the anticipated popularity of this unconventional real estate ownership,state legislation has blossomed in the past four years, and today, all but a few …

Inconsistent Taxation Of Grantor Powers, Leslie A. Nicholson, Iii

Vanderbilt Law Review

"Certainty," Lord Hardwicke declared in 1753, "is the mother of repose and therefore the law aims at certainty."' This note will explore the extent to which the law has missed the mark of certainty in the taxation of trust grantors. The heavy burden of federal income and estate taxation has prompted many persons to divest themselves of property during their lives. The property is usually given to a relative in order to shift the income from the property into a donee's lower tax bracket and to avoid the payment of an estate tax on the property by incurring an inter …

The Antitrust Laws And The Corporate Executive's Civil Damage Liability, Joseph R. Manning

Vanderbilt Law Review

It will be the purpose of this note to examine the executive's potential civil liability for damages resulting from his violations of the federal antitrust laws. First, there is the injury to the persons against whom his unlawful conduct was directed. They may desire compensation for their injuries, as well as treble damages in a suit authorized by section 4 of the Clayton Act.' Also, the executive may cause injury to his corporation by subjecting it to fines, damages,and litigation expenses. This presents the question: whether a shareholder may bring a derivative suit against the executive for these damages to …

Prologue, Joe L. Evins Mc

Vanderbilt Law Review

A more vivid awareness of the significance of small business to the economic structure of the nation must be cultivated. Those who have examined the role of the small businessman in our economy have emphasized repeatedly that a strong small business sector is essential to the preservation of our free enterprise system, the maintenance of a balance of economic and political power, and the assurance of a constant flow of new ideas and vigor into that system.

Expanding Jurisdiction Of The Federal Power Commission And The Problem Of Federal-State Conflict, William A. Campbell

Vanderbilt Law Review

After exploring federal-state conflicts in the granting of licenses for hydro-electric projects, it is clear that, thus far, the FPC has won most of the disputes; and this is not altogether bad, for there are certainly legitimate national interests to be protected here. But there are also legitimate state interests to be protected, not out of concern for the preservation of federalism as a political theory, but because the state is the political unit with the primary concern and responsibility for certain matters and because it can administer and regulate those matters with a higher degree of effectiveness than can …

A Symposium On Small Business, Eugene P. Foley

Vanderbilt Law Review

The diversified composition of small business frequently causes those unfamiliar with small business problems to despair of finding means to strengthen this vital segment of our economy. What can be done to help such an amorphous group develop a form that can withstand the pressures of a competitive society? There is no specialized material with which a small business can be coated, like a space capsule, to make it resistant to the heat and stresses of risk-taking in a profit and loss economy.

The Right To Effective Counsel In Criminal Cases, Ernest G. Kelly, Jr.

Vanderbilt Law Review

Under the Constitution of the United States as well as the laws of many states, a defendant in a criminal action is entitled not merely to the formality of representation by any counsel but also to some degree of efficacy in this representation. Determining whether this right to effective counsel has been violated is a difficult problem. One source of difficulty is the potential conflict between two strong public policy considerations: the desire to spare a defendant the injustices which can result from ineffective representation as opposed to the need for finality of judgments and the orderly functioning of the …

Equity -- 1964 Tennessee Survey, W. W. Garrett

Vanderbilt Law Review

In 1956 in the case of Langford v. Vanderbilt University, the Tennessee Supreme Court recognized the existence of a common law right of privacy. The Court of Appeals, Western Division, in Kyritsis v. Vieron, now holds that injunction does not lie to protect a personal right. The suit arose in the chancery court of Shelby County. Complainant alleged he was pastor of the Saint George's Greek Orthodox Church affiliated with the Greek Orthodox Church of North America and Canada, and that defendant was pastor of the Church of the Annunciation affiliated with the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of North and South …

Recent Developments Concerning Constitutional Limitations On State Defamation Laws, Samuel G. Mcnamara

Vanderbilt Law Review

Two recent cases, New York Times Co. v. Sullivan A and Garrison v. Louisiana, have over-turned many aspects of state laws regarding the defamation of public officials. The importance of these two cases is due not only to the problems they have solved, but also to the potential confusion which they have created. The primary purpose of this discussion is to point out the practical effect which the decisions will have on state law, both statutory and decisional. This note is concerned primarily with those aspects of the law of defamation dealing specifically with the conditional or qualified privilege to …

Recent Cases, Law Review Staff

Vanderbilt Law Review

Attorneys--Interstate Legal Services and the Unauthorized Practice of Law

==============================

Conflict of Laws--New York Public Policy Permits Enforcement of Foreign Gambling Obligation

===============================

Conscientious Objectors--Universal Military Training and Service Act--Supreme Court Test of"Belief In A Relation to A Supreme Being

===============================

Constitutional Law--Abatement of Convictions Occurring Prior to Passage of Civil Rights Act of 1964

===============================

Escheats--Disputes Between States Concerning Unclaimed Corporate Obligations

===============================

Labor Law--Failure To Bargain--Employer Required To Bargain With Respect to His Proposal To Contract Out Work

================================

Professions--Canon Twenty of the Canons of Professional Ethics Interpreted To Ban Statements to News Media

================================

Taxation--Corporate Income Taxation--Merger …

Decedents' Estates, Trusts And Future Interest -- 1964 Tennessee Survey, Herman L. Trautman

Vanderbilt Law Review

Validity of Instrument Which Only Appoints Fiduciary--Is an instrument which makes no testamentary gift, but only designates or appoints the personal representative to administer the estate and provides certain special powers of fiduciary administration entitled to probate as a valid will? While it has been said that there need be no dispositive gift of property to entitle a testamentary writing to probate as a will,' there seems to have been no definite court decision in Tennessee so holding until the recent case of Delaney v. First Peoples Bank of Johnson City. In that case a writing properly executed with the …

Torts -- 1964 Tennessee Survey, Dix W. Noel

Vanderbilt Law Review

As usual, the Tennessee appellate courts decided a considerable number of tort cases last year, covering a wide variety of problems.There were no striking new developments. In fact, the two decisions which were awaited by the profession with the greatest interest, Kyker v. General Motors Corporation' and Texas Tunneling Co. v. City of Chattanooga, tend to slow down some modem developments. In the Kyker case, it was indicated that manufacturers are not yet strictly liable in Tennessee, at least on warranty grounds, without privity of contract. In the Texas Tunneling case, a federal court undertaking to apply Tennessee law placed …

The Defense Establishment And The Domestic Economy, Adam Yarmolinsky

Vanderbilt Law Review

The first edition of Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations was published on the 9th of March, 1776, within four months of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. It was one of those rare occasions when history permits something to happen on a convenient date. For the principles of economics which Adam Smith expounded are an essential element in the structure and growth of American social thought, along with the principles of the Declaration of Independence itself. Their importance and relevance should not be obscured by the irrelevancies of economic fundamentalists, any more than their relevancies of constitutional fundamentalists can …

Agency -- 1964 Tennessee Survey, John S. Beasley

Vanderbilt Law Review

During the period covered by this Survey several cases have raised rather interesting points for consideration under the law of agency. On one occasion the Tennessee Supreme Court declined the opportunity of joining the ranks of the majority of states in moving toward a more modern rule on employer's liability with respect to an employee's child injured negligently by the employee. In this and other decisions, the courts have followed Tennessee precedent rather closely, with the result that there are few changes in the law of agency.