Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
- Publication Type
Articles 1 - 5 of 5
Full-Text Articles in Law
Supreme Court Reform And American Democracy, Ganesh Sitaraman, D. Epps
Supreme Court Reform And American Democracy, Ganesh Sitaraman, D. Epps
Vanderbilt Law School Faculty Publications
In How to Save the Supreme Court, we identified the legitimacy challenge facing the Court, traced it to a set of structural flaws, and proposed novel reforms. Little more than a year later, the conversation around Supreme Court reform has only grown louder and more urgent. In this Essay, we continue that conversation by engaging with critics of our approach. The current crisis of the Supreme Court is, we argue, inextricable from the question of the Supreme Court’s proper role in our democracy. For those interested in reform, there are three distinct strategies for ensuring the Supreme Court maintains its …
Justice Murphy: The Freshman Years, Woodford Howard
Justice Murphy: The Freshman Years, Woodford Howard
Vanderbilt Law Review
Justice Murphy is commonly regarded as having been a libertarian activist. He was not highly regarded as a Justice during his lifetime and this opinion prevails today. Here Professor Howard sees Justice Murphy during his early years on the Supreme Court as a man of indecision rather than an uncompromising libertarian. Through an examination of first amendment cases between 1940-42, the author finds that Murphy displayed a common reaction to the responsibilities of a new Supreme Court Justice which differed from most only in intensity.
Chief Justice Taft At The Helm, Alpheus T. Mason
Chief Justice Taft At The Helm, Alpheus T. Mason
Vanderbilt Law Review
The office of Chief Justice carries scant inherent powers. The Chief Justice manages the docket, presents the cases in conference, and guides the discussion. When in the majority, he assigns the writing of opinions. Whatever influence he exerts in the exercise of these prerogatives rests less on formal authority than on elusive personal characteristics. Charles Evans Hughes, who had served as Associate Justice from 1910 to 1916 and later had been able to observe Taft's role in the Court over a period of seven years, considered the Chief Justice "the most important judicial officer in the world." His actual power, …
Holmes And Brandeis: Companions In Dissent, Samuel J. Konefsky
Holmes And Brandeis: Companions In Dissent, Samuel J. Konefsky
Vanderbilt Law Review
In the 1920's, the words "Justices Holmes and Brandeis dissented" had become a familiar refrain in discussions about the work of the Supreme Court. This affinity between two men so unlike each other in background and method naturally puzzled the observers, and the effort to explain their relationship has produced two mutually contradictory theories. One view holds that though the two jurists approached problems differently, they usually arrived at the same conclusion because they shared a common philosophy on all really basic issues. "Oliver Wendell Holmes and Louis Dembitz Brandeis," a contemporary press comment read, "have achieved a spiritual kinship …
Book Reviews, Carl B. Swisher (Reviewer), Elvin E. Overton (Reviewer), Jay Murphy (Reviewer), Charlotte Williams (Reviewer), Alexander Holtzoff (Reviewer)
Book Reviews, Carl B. Swisher (Reviewer), Elvin E. Overton (Reviewer), Jay Murphy (Reviewer), Charlotte Williams (Reviewer), Alexander Holtzoff (Reviewer)
Vanderbilt Law Review
Book Reviews
LIONS UNDER THE THRONE
By Charles P. Curtis, Jr.
Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1947. Pp. xviii, 368. $3.50
MR. JUSTICE BLACK: THE MAN AND His OPINIONS
By John P. Frank (Introduction by Charles A. Beard)
New York: Knopf Company, 1949.Pp. xix, 357. $4.00
ON UNDERSTANDING THE SUPREME COURT
By Paul A. Freund
Boston: Little, Brown & Co., 1949. Pp. vi, 130. $3.00
MELVILLE VESTON FULLER: CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE UNITED STATES, 1888-1919
By Willard L. King
New York: Macmillan Company, 1950. Pp.394. $5.00
CHIEF JUSTICE STONE AND THE SUPREME COURT
By Samuel J. Konefsky (Prefatory Note by Charles A. …