Law Commons^™

Dumping Emtala: Restoring The Fiduciary Ethic, Improving Community Care, And Increasing Efficiency Through The Membership Model, Joseph A. Gonzalez

Joseph A Gonzalez

The U.S. healthcare system is breaking. Hospital emergency departments ("EDs") disproportionately bear this burden. EMTALA, the federal law that mandates treatment in an emergency, is responsible. By forcing a hospital to provide medical treatment, despite a patient's inability to pay, EMTALA has altered treatment standards for the worse. In this note, I suggest that repealing EMTALA will allow the market to capture the treatment values that motivated EMTALA's passage. Permitting EDs to base treatment on a patient's pre-existing hospital membership encourages better treatment than EMTALA. A market driven ED will succeed where EMTALA has failed.