Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Articles 1 - 1 of 1
Full-Text Articles in Law
Alternative Liability And Deprivation Of Remedy: Teaching Old Tort Law New Tricks, Adam L. Fletcher
Alternative Liability And Deprivation Of Remedy: Teaching Old Tort Law New Tricks, Adam L. Fletcher
Cleveland State Law Review
The problems presented by “tortfeasor indeterminacy” are perhaps the greatest remaining point of contention in the otherwise generally overlooked requirement of cause-in-fact. The issue is deceptively simple; several defendants have breached a duty to the plaintiff and one of their breaches is the cause-in-fact of plaintiff's injury, but it is impossible to tell which one. As a result, the plaintiff cannot meet his evidentiary burden on the element of cause-in-fact and is unable to recover. In response to the plaintiff's dilemma, courts have developed the doctrines of “alternative liability” and “market-share liability.” Yet many courts and commentators have rejected these …