Law Commons^™

The International Joint Commission And Great Lakes Diversions: Indirectly Extending The Reach Of The Boundary Waters Treaty, A. Dan Tarlock

All Faculty Scholarship

The 1909 Boundary Waters Treaty (Treaty) is a model of, international water resources cooperation because it provides a permanent dispute mechanism, the six member International Joint Commission (IJC). Thus, both Canada and the United States have much to celebrate on the 100th anniversary of the Treaty. However, the most interesting aspect of the Treaty is the regime's ability to evolve through state practice beyond its original dispute resolution function, despite the inconsistent support for IJC involvement in transboundary water issues of the United States. The Treaty has been severely criticized by governments and non-governmental organizations (NGOs), especially in, Canada, for …

Cultural Norms As A Source Of Law: The Example Of Bottled Water, Christine A. Klein, Ling-Yee Huang

UF Law Faculty Publications

As a metaphor for the interaction of law and culture, bottled water is striking in its simplicity and clarity. Bottled water consumers form a surprisingly loyal subculture of beverage drinkers, united by the water truths and water myths that they embrace. More recently, an equally fervent subculture of bottled water protestors has begun to coalesce. Notably, the cultural norms associated with both supporters and detractors extend beyond mere hydration and encompass such fundamental and varied notions as health, taste, convenience, status, morality, anti-privatization, sustainability, and truth-telling. In contrast to the cultural story, the legal narrative is surprisingly sparse, overlooking an …

Water Security, Fear Mitigation And International Water Law (Symposium), A. Dan Tarlock

All Faculty Scholarship

Water lawyers, courts, and others in the water community are fond of quoting the quip attributed to Mark Twain, "whiskey is for drinking and water is for fighting over." Not only is there no evidence that Twain ever uttered these words, but the quote has taken on a life of its own which grossly distorts the nature of water competition disputes, especially state to state competition. Both whiskey and water are for human benefit and exist in sufficient quantities throughout the world to satisfy present and future demand. Meeting these demands will be challenging because water must be managed to …

Comprehensive River Basin Management: The Limits Of Collaborative, Stakeholder-Based, Water Governance, James L. Huffman

James L. Huffman

The allocation of scarce, freshwater resources is complicated by the transboundary nature of most, significant, surface water sources. These jurisdictional challenges exist across national borders and within federal nations like the United States. An obvious and long advocated solution is the creation of river basin authorities to bridge jurisdictional boundaries. This paper examines the rationale for river basin water management, describes several examples of river basin management regimes in the United States and other nations, and explains why many such schemes have failed or experienced limited success. Although there is much enthusiasm for collaborative integrated management of water and associated …

Freshwater Conservation: A Review Of Oregon Water Law & Policy, Adell L. Amos

Adell L. Amos

In order to more fully understand and enhance freshwater conservation in the State of Oregon, The Nature Conservancy initiated a project to conduct a legal and policy review of Oregon water law. In Oregon, like all western states, water management is based on a combination of statutes, administrative rules, agency policies, and case law. Accordingly, this report identifies and explains relevant provisions of the Oregon Water Code and discusses how the legislature, state administrative agencies, and the courts have interpreted the law. The report also identifies the impacts and implications of legal and policy choices that have been made with …

The Last Stand Of The Wild West: Twenty-First Century Water Wars In Southern California, Shannon M. Baker-Branstetter

Shannon M Baker-Branstetter

In 2003, the Imperial Irrigation District of California agreed to transfer water from rural Imperial County to urban Southern California cities as part of a quantitative settlement agreement (QSA). The Colorado River water that the Imperial Irrigation District (IID) transferred to the wealthy coastal cities was held in trust for the residents of the Imperial Valley, the poorest county in the State. The following paper asserts that the IID Board of Directors breached its trust to the residents and farmers of Imperial County when it sold water rights to municipal districts in Southern California, thus acerbating the poor economic conditions …

Cultural Norms As A Source Of Law: The Example Of Bottled Water, Christine A. Klein

Christine A. Klein

As a metaphor for the interaction of law and culture, a crystal-clear bottle of water is striking in its simplicity and purity. Bottled water has spawned a rich subculture of beverage drinkers, united by the truths and myths of bottled water that they embrace. More recently, an equally fertile subculture of bottled water protest has begun to coalesce. Notably, the cultural norms evidenced by supporters and detractors go far beyond mere hydration, touching upon such far-flung notions as health, taste, convenience, status, morality, anti-privatization, sustainability, and truth-telling. In contrast, the legal narrative is surprisingly sparse, overlooking an important opportunity to …

El Precia Del Agua [Pricing Water], Carlos Gómez-Ligüerre, Vanessa Casado-Pérez, Ignacio Marín-García

Faculty Scholarship

En España, como en otros muchos países, el agua es un recurso escaso que se asigna ineficientemente. El Estado es su propietario y la asigna a precios políticos e inadecuados. Mientras que la agricultura absorbe dos tercios de este preciado bien, los hogares y la industria consumen sólo el 18 y el 13 % respectivamente. Este trabajo propone la creación de un mercado de derechos sobre el agua controlado por una agencia estatal, pues los costes de transacción son tan elevados que el resultado alcanzado a través de la negociación libre entre las partes no sería eficiente.

In Spain, as …

Justice Kennedy And Ecosystem Services: A Functional Approach To Clean Water Act Jurisdiction After Rapanos, Robin K. Craig

Robin K. Craig

Justice Kennedy’s “significant nexus” test may emerge as the proverbial silver lining of the U.S. Supreme Court’s June 2006 decision in Rapanos v. United States, at least so far as recognition of ecosystem services is concerned. The Court’s opinion in Rapanos was fractured. Nevertheless, it left no doubts that the Clean Water Act’s jurisdiction over “navigable waters” had been limited, drawing criticism for both its lack of clarity and its restriction of federal jurisdiction under the Act.

The extent of that restriction, however, would depend on which of the three major opinion’s in the case – Justice Scalia’s plurality, Justice …

Cultural Norms As A Source Of Law: The Example Of Bottled Water, Christine A. Klein, Ling-Yee Huang

Christine A. Klein

As a metaphor for the interaction of law and culture, a crystal-clear bottle of water is striking in its simplicity and purity. Bottled water has spawned a rich subculture of beverage drinkers, united by the truths and myths of bottled water that they embrace. More recently, an equally fertile subculture of bottled water protest has begun to coalesce. Notably, the cultural norms evidenced by supporters and detractors go far beyond mere hydration, touching upon such far-flung notions as health, taste, convenience, status, morality, truth-telling, and anti-privatization. In contrast, the legal narrative is surprisingly sparse, overlooking an important opportunity to engage …

California Water Law: Historical Origins To The Present, Roderick E. Walston

Roderick E. Walston

No abstract provided.

Advancing Freshwater Conservation In The Context Of Energy And Climate Policy: Assessing Progress And Identifying Challenges In The Western United States, Adell L. Amos

Adell L. Amos

This article critically evaluates freshwater conservation efforts in light of energy and climate policy in the western United States. Many, if not all, governmental entities today are facing tough and controversial questions involving energy demand and consumption. In the western United States, these energy questions are often inextricably linked to water resource availability and demand issues. With increased population and development pressure the challenges involving energy and water are likely to increase. Moreover, as the impacts from changes to climate and weather patterns increase various areas of the country will see changes to precipitation patterns, increased drought cycles, increased storm …

A Line Drawn In Water: Aquifers Beneath The Mexico-United States Border, Paul Stanton Kibel

Paul Stanton Kibel

No abstract provided.

Water Leadership And The Rights Of Youth To Sustainable Development, Prof. Elizabeth Burleson

Prof. Elizabeth Burleson

Reasonable and equitable use of water can help achieve local, regional, and international peace and security. This Article addresses water security around the world. Lack of safe drinking water and sanitation kills roughly 4500 children a day according to the World Health Organization. Youth have an important role to play as stakeholders with the longest range interests in policy outcomes. We have a shared responsibility to ensure water access and water quality. This Article concludes that clean technology transfer in particular and international cooperation generally can facilitate informed decisions upon which egalitarian agreements can establish sustainable watershed management.