Law Commons^™

Engines By Ge, Body By Houdini: State Secrets As A Procedural Restraint To The Resolution Of Disputes, Les Schiefelbein

Les Schiefelbein

Virtually every national government has a state secrets doctrine. The doctrine is best defined as “any information that, if disclosed publicly, would be reasonably likely to cause significant harm to the national defense or foreign relations of a government.”

Let me give state secrets some practical context and review how it is applied in the United Kingdom, the United States and France.

The best aviation description of my comments on state secrets is “Engines By GE, Body By Houdini.” The illusionist reference is an aviation descriptor of stealth airplanes whose invisibility to radar detection is like the state secret doctrine …

Abortion In South Africa And The United States: An Integrative, Contrastive Comparative Analysis Of The Effect Of Legal And Cultural Influences On Implementation Of Abortion Rights, Danielle Y. Blanks

Danielle Y Blanks

Despite similarly progressive abortion rights laws, women in South Africa and the U.S. experience completely different levels of access to legal and safe abortions. In this paper, I will seek to explain the reasons for this disparity by describing the ways in which natural law has influenced the application of law in the U.S. and South Africa while examining the role of cultural values in the realization of abortion rights. I will take an integrative approach to explain ideological similarities and a contrastive approach to denote the cultural differences that have led to a de facto marginalization of South African …

Transformation Of Trust Ideas In Japan: Drafting Of The Trust Act 1922, Masayuki Tamaruya

Masayuki Tamaruya

No abstract provided.

Adequacy Of Representation In Argentina: Federal Supreme Court’S Case Law, Bills Pending Before Congress And The Preliminary Draft Of A New Civil Code, Francisco Verbic

Francisco Verbic

The paper describes how adequacy of representation has recently arrived to Argentina’s legal system in the field of representative litigation. First of all, in the FederalSupreme Court’s case law. Then, in some bills which are nowadays pending before Congress. Lastly, in the Preliminary Draft of a new Civil Code recently announced by the President and the Chief Justice of the Federal Supreme Court. I take a critical approach towards the issue, particularly because of the little attention paid to such a relevant aspect of representative proceedings

Consumer Class Actions In Argentina And Brazil. Comparative Analysis And Enforcement Of Foreign Judgments, Francisco Verbic

Francisco Verbic

No abstract provided.

What's Beneath The Graham Cracker?: The Potential Impact Of Comparative Law On The Future Of Juvenile Justice Reform After Graham V. Florida, David A. Shapiro

David A Shapiro

The United States continues to incarcerate children for longer periods than any other country. It remains perhaps the only country in the world to sentence juveniles to life without parole. It has violated the most basic of international legal conventions, including the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). It is time to bring juvenile sentencing and reforms in line with the rest of the civilized world. There are more than two hundred different countries with their own juvenile sentencing and reform laws.

This article argues that reformers are better off looking to these countries directly than …

Rape Trauma, The State, And The Art Of Tracey Emin, Yxta M. Murray

Yxta M. Murray

Prosecutors use “rape trauma syndrome” evidence at rape trials to explain victims’ “counterintuitive” behaviors and demeanors, such as late reporting, denying their rapes, returning to the scenes of their attacks, and lack of emotional affect. Courts and experts, in instructions and testimony, usually describe victim reticence as a product of “shame” or “trauma.” Feminist critics of R.T.S. evidence posit that it is based on incomplete evidence, because most rapes are unreported. Furthermore, they object to its condescending, sexist, and colonial construction of rape victims and their emotions. In this Article, I respond to feminist critics by studying the work of …

Beyond Macro-Prudential Regulation: Three Ways Of Thinking About Financial Crisis, Regulation And Reform, Tamara Lothian

Tamara Lothian

This paper considers the debate about the "macro-prudential regulation" of finance in the context of a broader view of the relation of finance to the real economy. Five ideas are central to the argument. The first idea is that the two dominant families of ideas about finance and its regulation share a failure of institutional imagination. Neoclassical economists blame localized market and regulatory failures for the troubles of finance. Keynesians invoke the way in which the money economy may amplify cycles of despondency and euphoria. Neither current of thought recognizes that the institutions of finance in particular, and of the …

Democracy And The Western Legal Tradition, Mauro Bussani

Mauro Bussani

The availability of democracy is usually presented as a pre-requisite of any evaluation – be it political, economic or legal – of any country, and as an imperative to pursue (with or without Western help) for all societies that do not enjoy it. Yet, discussions about non-democratic systems, and the Western aspiration to transform them, often fail to take into account – as they actually should – the basic elements of Western democratic societies, the very fabric with which democracy is woven. The paper adopts a comparative law approach to the issue. It takes into account the historical, technical, and …

Vietnam, China, And The United States: The Regulatory Framework Of Mining Pollution And Water Quality, Heather Whitney

Heather Whitney

This paper compares the environmental, mining, and water quality policy and regulatory framework of three countries: Vietnam, China, and the United States. There are many similarities between China and Vietnam’s legal framework and environmental protection mechanisms, by virtue of the fact that they are both socialist countries, both authoritarian governments, and both in the midst of an industrial revolution. The United States intersects in some areas of water quality standards and technological controls of effluents with both countries, as well as certain enforcement measures. This is true especially in China, where the EPA has actively consulted the Chinese government in …

Does Mass Product Tort Litigation Facilitate Or Hinder Social Legislative Reform? A Comparative Study Of Tobacco Regulation, Jeffrey S. Quinn

Jeffrey S Quinn

This Article, Does Mass Product Tort Litigation Facilitate or Hinder Social Legislative Reform? A Comparative Study of Tobacco Regulation, analyzes the competing arguments for and against the use of tort litigation as a means of creating social reform. The value of current scholarship is limited because authors frequently allow their biases to influence their conclusions. Authors in favor of public health reform argue in favor of using tort litigation to create social reform, while authors in favor of a strict separation of powers approach argue against using tort litigation to create social reform. This Article, however, synthesizes the scholarly debate …

¿Viva La Data Protection? Chile As A Touchstone For The Future Of Information Privacy, Nicola C. Menaldo

Nicola C. Menaldo

This paper attempts to uncover a puzzle: although the traditional levers for strong privacy protection are present in Chile – a history of dictatorship, an information technology revolution, and strong trade with the European Union – its data protection laws are in fact very weak. What explains this apparent disconnect? This paper challenges the conventional wisdom: that Chile's weak data protection regime is the result of weak democratic institutions, collective action problems, or the prioritization of credit data protections. Instead, it argues that Chile's stunted regime results from a political culture in which privacy protections, generally, are traded off for …

Fragile Merchandise: A Comparative Analysis Of The Privacy Rights For Public Figures, Scott Shackelford

Scott Shackelford

Over a century after Warren and Brandeis first presented the right to U.S. jurists for their consideration, privacy has become a central player in U.S. law. But nations around the world, in particular the common and civil law nations of Europe that share similar legal cultures with the United States, are grappling with how best to strike a balance between the competing rights of privacy and freedom of expression—both of which are critical to the functioning of democratic society. Existing literature has not fully drawn from this reservoir of international experience to inform the debate about U.S. privacy rights. This …

Taking War Seriously: A Model For Constitutional Constraints On The Use Of Force, In Compliance With International Law, Craig Martin

Craig Martin

This article develops an argument for increased constitutional control over the decision to use armed force or engage in armed conflict, as a means of reducing the incidence of illegitimate armed conflict. In particular, the Model would involve three elements: a process-based constitutional incorporation of the principles of international law relating to the use of force (the jus ad bellum regime); a constitutional requirement that the legislature approve any use of force rising above a de minimus level; and an explicit provision for limited judicial review of the decision-making process. The Model is not designed with any one country in …

A Pluralist Approach To Mixed Jurisdictions, Mauro Bussani

Mauro Bussani

The paper claims that ‘mixity’ is an inherent quality of almost any legal systems, and not only of those that, for historical reasons, inherited legal features from the civil and common law traditions. From this ‘pluralistic’ point of view, all the experiences where Western legal models interact among themselves, or with religious, indigenous or customary laws, deserve to be included into the ‘mixed’ category. Such an approach reveals itself as a powerful cognitive tool to advance comparative knowledge about legal systems. In particular, it enables one to better understand: (a) the dynamism of any given legal system – be it …

A Balancing Act? The Rights Of Donor-Conceived Children To Know Their Biological Origins, Brigitte J. Clark Dr

Brigitte J Clark Dr

Internationally, donor-conceived children’s rights to know their biological origins have been recognised to some extent by the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). With the drafting of the Article 7 (1) of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), as supplemented by Article 8, such children’s rights to know their biological origins whist they are children, and not only later as adults, were acknowledged for the first time, though not explicitly. Anonymous sperm donation is now banned in eleven jurisdictions, including Sweden and England and Wales. By contrast, France still does not expressly …

The Right To Food And Buyer Power, Aravind Ganesh

Aravind Ganesh

Modern global food supply chains are characterised by extreme levels of concentration in the middle of those chains. This paper argues that such concentration leads to excessive buyer power, which harms the consumers and food producers at the ends of the supply chains. This paper argues that the harms suffered by farmers are serious enough as to constitute violations of the international human right to food as it is expressed in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Political Rights, and further argues that world competition law regimes cannot ignore these human rights …

Acontextual Judicial Review, Louis Michael Seidman

Louis Michael Seidman

Is constitutional judicial review a necessary component of a just polity? A striking feature of the current debate is its tendency to proceed as if the question could be answered in the same way always and everywhere. Defenders of constitutional review argue that is a conceptually necessary feature of constitutionalism, the rule of law, and the effective protection of individual rights. Critics claim that it is necessarily inconsistent with progressive politics and democratic engagement. Largely missing from the debate is a fairly obvious point: Like any other institution, constitutional review must be evaluated within a particular temporal, cultural, and political …

Uncitral, Security Rights And The Globalisation Of The Us Article 9, Gerard Mccormack Professor

Gerard McCormack

Abstract – “UNCITRAL, Security Rights and the globalisation of the US Article 9” UNCITRAL, the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, has recently produced a Legislative Guide on more particularly on secured transactions, or secured credit law as it is variously called. The Guide follows the broad contours of Article 9 of the United States Uniform Commercial Code though it is not an exact copy. It aims to harmonise and modernise the law of secured credit across the globe. In UNCITRAL’s view, the Legislative Guide will aid the growth of individual businesses and also in general economic prosperity. Harmonisation …

Making Wto Remedies Work For Developing Nations: The Need For Class Actions, Phoenix X. Cai

Phoenix X. Cai

Making WTO Remedies Work for Developing Nations: The Need for Class Actions

Abstract

Developing nations comprise more than four-fifths of the membership of the World Trade Organization (“WTO”). Yet, they seldom participate in the WTO’s powerful dispute settlement process. This is problematic because the WTO is essentially a self-enforcing system of reciprocal trade rights that relies on proactive monitoring and enforcement by all members. Use of the self-enforcement mechanism – by initiating cases under the WTO’s Dispute Settlement Understanding (“DSU”) - is critical.

There are five primary reasons why developing nations do not actively invoke the DSU. This Article argues …

E-Elections: Time For Japan To Embrace Online Campaigning, Matthew J. Wilson

Matthew J. Wilson

Asia has embraced the Internet and social media. Japan and South Korea rank among the world’s leaders in technological innovation and Internet penetration. China boasts over 420 million Internet users, and other Asian countries have experienced the widespread acceptance of online technologies. With the rapid ascendency of the Internet and social media, however, Asian countries have sometimes struggled with striking the proper balance between individual rights and the legal regulation of online activities. One prime example of such struggle involves the clash between Japan’s election laws and individual political freedoms.

Although Japan generally subscribes to democratic traditions and the principle …

Auditors' Multi-Layered Liability Regime, Paolo E. Giudici

Paolo E. Giudici

The proposals to limit auditor liability, principally aimed at protecting the Big-4 from the risk of a catastrophic exposure to damages, are grounded on the assumption that auditors are generally over-deterred. The 2008 EC Commission Recommendation on auditor liability relies heavily on this assumption and the economic rationale that underpins it, which is entirely focused on liability towards investors and the US narrative concerning securities class actions. However, the case is much more complex. Any discussion about auditor liability must investigate the following questions: who the auditor’s principals are; whether they are in a position to negotiate in order to …

Glimmers Of Hope: The Evolution Of Equality Rights Doctrine In Japanese Courts From A Comparative Perspective, Craig Martin

Craig Martin

There has been little study of the analytical framework employed by the Japanese courts in resolving constitutional claims under the right to be treated as an equal and not be discriminated against. In the Japanese literature the only comparative analysis done focuses on American equal protection jurisprudence. This article examines the development of the equality rights doctrine in the Japanese Supreme Court from the perspective of an increasingly universal “proportionality analysis” approach to rights enforcement, of which the Canadian equality rights jurisprudence is a good example, in contrast to the American approach. This comparative analysis, which begins with a review …

Rethinking Preventive Measures For Money Laundering And Terrorism Financing, Richard K. Gordon

Richard K Gordon

Preventive measures for money laundering and terrorism financing are among the most widely accepted and observed global standards. However, there is substantial evidence that they do not work well. A main reason is that private sector parties, mostly financial institutions but including few others, are tasked with duties for which they are ill suited, while too little is required of the public sector . While they are required to monitor client transactions and reporting those that raise suspicion of money laundering or terrorism financing, they do not have sufficient expertise or data access to do so. Also, as suggested by …

The Emergence Of East Asia Constitutionalism: Features In Comparison, Wen-Chen Chang, Jiunn-Rong Yeh

Wen-Chen Chang

Vibrant constitutional democracies have taken hold in East Asian soil. Japan, South Korea and Taiwan came to mind as successful examples. Scant attention, however, has been placed upon ways that constitutionalism has been brought into being and developed into distinctive forms in East Asia. This paper seeks to analyze in a descriptively way constitutional developments in Japan, South Korea and Taiwan. By reading the three cases together, this paper discerns a number of common features shared by the three constitutional developments, which include instrumental constitutional state building, textual and institutional continuity, reactive judicial review and a wide range of rights …

The Emergence Of East Asia Constitutionalism: Features In Comparison, Wen-Chen Chang, Jiunn-Rong Yeh

Wen-Chen Chang

Vibrant constitutional democracies have taken hold in East Asian soil. Japan, South Korea and Taiwan came to mind as successful examples. Scant attention, however, has been placed upon ways that constitutionalism has been brought into being and developed into distinctive forms in East Asia. This paper seeks to analyze in a descriptively way constitutional developments in Japan, South Korea and Taiwan. By reading the three cases together, this paper discerns a number of common features shared by the three constitutional developments, which include instrumental constitutional state building, textual and institutional continuity, reactive judicial review and a wide range of rights …

Specialized Courts For Terrorism Trials, Sudha Setty

Sudha Setty

On the campaign trail in 2008, presidential candidate and then-Senator Barack Obama promised to restore America’s place in the world by breaking with many of the national security policies put into effect by President George W. Bush. In January 2009, President Obama made numerous changes to United States foreign policy, including signing an executive order to close the prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba and announcing that the United States would not engage in interrogation techniques that constitute torture. In some aspects of national security law and policy, however, Obama has followed the example of President Bush—for example, in his announcement …

The Emergence Of East Asia Constitutionalism: Features In Comparison, Wen-Chen Chang, Jiunn-Rong Yeh

Wen-Chen Chang

Vibrant constitutional democracies have taken hold in East Asian soil. Japan, South Korea and Taiwan came to mind as successful examples. Scant attention, however, has been placed upon ways that constitutionalism has been brought into being and developed into distinctive forms in East Asia. This paper seeks to analyze in a descriptively way constitutional developments in Japan, South Korea and Taiwan. By reading the three cases together, this paper discerns a number of common features shared by the three constitutional developments, which include instrumental constitutional state building, textual and institutional continuity, reactive judicial review and a wide range of rights …

Deconstructing Transnationalism: Conceptualizing Metanationalism As A Putative Model Of Evolving Jurisprudence, Paul Enríquez

Paul Enriquez

This Article builds upon Philip C. Jessup’s revolutionary scholarship to pave new pathways for interdisciplinary research and expand the normative constitutional framework of universal human problems. To that end, this Article ties American constitutional theory to the new era of international globalization and provides context that facilitates the discussion of racial and ethnic diversity in education from a domestic and international perspective. By arguing for compelling treatment of diversity in elementary and secondary learning institutions, this Article introduces a new theory of constitutional interpretation vis-à-vis international law. This theory, called metanationalism, rejects Harold Koh’s theory of transnationalism and demonstrates that …

Is Tax Law Culturally Specific? Lessons From The History Of Income Tax Law In Mandatory Palestine, Assaf Likhovski

Assaf Likhovski

Tax law is a technical area of law which does not seem to be culturally specific. It is thus seen as easily transferable between different societies and cultures. However, tax law is also based on definitions and notions which are not universal (the private sphere, the family, the gift etc.). So, is tax law universal or particular? Is it indeed easily transferable between different societies? And in what ways does tax law reflect ethnic or cultural rather than economic differences? This Article seeks to answer these questions by analyzing one specific example — the history of income tax legislation in …