Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Law Commons

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Articles 1 - 14 of 14

Full-Text Articles in Law

Suicide Responsibility Of Hospital And Psychiatrist, Irwin N. Perr Jan 1960

Suicide Responsibility Of Hospital And Psychiatrist, Irwin N. Perr

Cleveland State Law Review

The problem of suicide is a prominent public health problem in this country. Physicians and hospitals have an obvious concern, as do the law courts, where actions for wrongful death and negligence may involve suicide as a result of a tortious act. This paper will restrict comment to the principles and application of present law as to the responsibility of the psychiatric hospital and the psychiatrist and a discussion of some of the applicable psychiatric factors.


An Appraisal Of Competency, Henry Davidson Jan 1960

An Appraisal Of Competency, Henry Davidson

Cleveland State Law Review

Competence is the ability to handle business affairs with ordinary prudence. It is a legal not a medical formula, and in a sense, it must be defined negatively. Every one is assumed to be competent. If you think some one is incompetent, you must prove it. He does not have to prove that he is competent. Therefore, the formula is a criterion of incompetency not competency. To declare a person incompetent, these findings must coexist: 1. He has a mental disorder. 2. This causes bad judgment. 3. Because of the bad judgment, the patient either: (a) Squanders his money or …


Hospital Privileges Revisited, Irwin N. Perr Jan 1960

Hospital Privileges Revisited, Irwin N. Perr

Cleveland State Law Review

It is the opinion of this writer that the laws relating to hospital privileges basically are sound and in the public interest.There is no clear reason to overthrow the accumulated wisdom of the last hundred years. American hospitals have become the best in the world because of the freedom with which they have been allowed to function. This does not militate against the constant march for improvement. As can be seen, there are cases where individuals are handicapped in their use of hospitals.These situations reflect social problems, not defects in existing laws which, like our Constitutional rights, sometimes are somewhat …


Book Review, Raymond L. Shilling Jan 1960

Book Review, Raymond L. Shilling

Cleveland State Law Review

Reviewing Fred A. Mettler, The Medical Sourcebook, Little, Brown and Company, 1959


Discovery Of Medical Records, Margaret Mazza Jan 1960

Discovery Of Medical Records, Margaret Mazza

Cleveland State Law Review

Medical evidence is employed by plaintiffs chiefly to prove the causation and extent of personal injury damages, while defendants try to prove the slightness or lack of causal connection in such claims. Many types of medical reports are kept which may be used to substantiate the allegations of either party in personal injury actions. Of primary importance are the reports of physicians and hospitals, and reports upon the voluntary or compulsory examination of the plaintiff.


Book Review, Carl E. Wasmuth Jan 1960

Book Review, Carl E. Wasmuth

Cleveland State Law Review

Reviewing Paul David Cantor, Traumatic Medicine and Surgery for the Attorney; Vol. I - The Traumatic Problem, Central Book Co., 1959


Standard Of Care Of Medical General Practitioners, Milton Oppenheim Jan 1960

Standard Of Care Of Medical General Practitioners, Milton Oppenheim

Cleveland State Law Review

The law takes into account such matters as differences in various schools or systems of medicine, the state of medical acumen and knowledge, the established mode of practice, the locality, and conditions of practice. To reach a logical standard for physicians, and especially for that segment of the profession designated as "the general practitioner," various requirements are recognized by the law. Some courts insist that the degree of care and skill shall be commensurate with the advanced state of the science at the time of rendition of the service. This concept of the amount or degree of scientific medicine must …


Res Ipsa Loquitur In Hospital And Malpractice Cases, Julien C. Renswick Jan 1960

Res Ipsa Loquitur In Hospital And Malpractice Cases, Julien C. Renswick

Cleveland State Law Review

Most legal texts state as a matter of law that in order to apply the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur it is required that plaintiff show that the instrumentality causing his injury was in the continuous and exclusive control of one defendant. This general proposition has been stated in Ohio on several occasions. However, in the last few years some exceptions to this general rule have been established in several jurisdictions.


Administrator's View Of Doctor-Lawyer-Hospital Relations, Thomas Hale Jr. Jan 1960

Administrator's View Of Doctor-Lawyer-Hospital Relations, Thomas Hale Jr.

Cleveland State Law Review

In the September 1959 issue of the Cleveland-Marshall Law Reivew, Mr. Howard Oleck, Assistant Dean and Professor of Law of the School, has written an article discussing the legal relationships of physician, lawyer, and hospital administrator. While he addresses himself primarily to the legal relationships between these three groups, his article also concerns itself to some extent with the professional and administrative relationships involved. The article then goes on to discuss the case of Morwin v. Albany Hospital, and certain conclusions are drawn from the author's interpretation of this case which he applies to the "triangle" of doctor, lawyer, and …


Lawyer Meets Forensic Pathologist, George E. Hall Jan 1960

Lawyer Meets Forensic Pathologist, George E. Hall

Cleveland State Law Review

Forensic medicine is that part of medical science which is employed by the legal authorities for the solution of legal problems. Theoretically all branches of medicine may be included in this definition, for the law has used them all when need has arisen, and any doctor who testifies in court in his professional capacity can be considered a practitioner of legal medicine. The forensic pathologist is a trained pathologist who concentrates his efforts on the investigation of deaths which have occurred as result of violence or under suspicious circumstances.


Anesthesiology And The Law - In The Long View, Carl E. Wasmuth Jan 1960

Anesthesiology And The Law - In The Long View, Carl E. Wasmuth

Cleveland State Law Review

Anesthesiology is the youngest of the medical specialties. Born of surgical parents, it was nurtured through its infancy by well-meaning and dedicated physicians. Even now this specialty is one of the most litigated fields of medicine, rivaling radiology, surgery, and plastic surgery. This, however, is at best a dubious distinction. Considering the nature of the specialty, one can easily understand the reason. In the hands of the anesthesiologist rests the life of every patient undergoing a surgical operation.


Hospital Refusal To Release Mental Patient, Thomas S. Szasz Jan 1960

Hospital Refusal To Release Mental Patient, Thomas S. Szasz

Cleveland State Law Review

This paper was intended as a contribution to the study of psychiatry, and especially institutional psychiatry, as a form of social control. More specifically, I have sought to present further evidence in support of the thesis that the relationship between the involuntarily hospitalized mental patient and his psychiatrist (s) is commonly antagonistic rather than cooperative in nature. The conception of a "mental illness," as essentially similar to a bodily disease, serves to obscure the many exceedingly significant socio-economic, legal and ethical aspects of forced mental hospitalization.The patient's lawsuit for release, and the psychiatric superintendent's appeal that he be permitted to …


Epilepsy - Post-Traumatic Or Not, Irwin N. Perr Jan 1960

Epilepsy - Post-Traumatic Or Not, Irwin N. Perr

Cleveland State Law Review

This article discusses the legal issues presented in Muscarello v. Peterson. The case presents clearly the medical aspects in ascertaining whether epilepsy is a result of injury or is a result of independent factors. As the court stated, the decision rests basically on medical evidence and its evaluation by the jury.


Standards Of Care In Dentistry, Jerome A. Streem Jan 1960

Standards Of Care In Dentistry, Jerome A. Streem

Cleveland State Law Review

This article will discuss briefly each of the three sources of liability for which a dentist might commonly be subject to a malpractice suit: negligence, assault and battery, and breach of contract.