Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®
Articles 1 - 1 of 1
Full-Text Articles in Law
Conditional Rules In Criminal Procedure: Alice In Wonderland Meets The Constitution, David Rossman
Conditional Rules In Criminal Procedure: Alice In Wonderland Meets The Constitution, David Rossman
Faculty Scholarship
Without recognizing that it has done so, the Supreme Court has created a category of constitutional rules of criminal procedure that are all in a peculiar format, conditional rules. A conditional rule depends on some future event to determine whether one has failed to honor it. In a wide variety of contexts, if a police officer, prosecutor, judge or defense attorney does something that the Constitution regulates, one cannot determine if the constitutional rule has been violated or not until some point in the future.
The Court has used three methods to create these rules. One looks to prejudice, and …