Law Commons^™

Bargaining With Double Jeopardy, Saul Levmore, Ariel Porat

Ariel Porat

Virtually every burden of proof is influenced by a rule regarding relitigation. In criminal law, the prosecutor is prevented from repeatedly drawing from the urn, as it were, by the double jeopardy rule, which reinforces the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard. We suggest that if law were to permit the defendant to waive the double jeopardy protection, private and social benefits might follow. The benefits derive from the likelihood that the prosecutor – like most people who can take a test but once – will overinvest in preparation. Somewhat similarly, though far afield, deficit spending by a legislature might be linked to the …