Law Commons^™

The Judicial Independence Of Canadian Forces General Court Martials: An Analysis Of The Supreme Court Of Canada Judgment In R. V. Genereux, Michael Doi

Dalhousie Law Journal

In R. v. Genereux, the Supreme Court of Canada reviewed the structure of a Canadian Forces General Court Martial and found it to incorporate features which reasonably called its judicial independence into question. This was held to violate the rights of accused military personnel to a fair trial under sub-section 11(d) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. In arriving at this conclusion, the Supreme Court of Canada questioned the legitimacy of Canadian Forces provisions which structure a judicial process governing service personnel as separate and distinct members from the rest of the general population. The Court also reviewed …