Digital Commons Network^™

Standardized Terms And Conditions For Open Patenting, Mariateresa Maggiolino, Maria Lillà Montagnani

mariateresa maggiolino

Once given a legal characterization of the open patenting phenomenon and discussed many of the empirical and theoretical experiences dealing with both open innovation and defensive patenting, the paper suggests what standardized terms and conditions a patent license should encompass in order to foster both the free movement of patented knowledge and its business applications.

Copyright Fee Shifting: A Proposal To Promote Fair Use And Fair Licensing, Ben Depoorter

Ben Depoorter

The fair use doctrine seeks to facilitate socially optimal uses of copyrighted material. As a practical matter, however, cumulative creators, such as documentary filmmakers and many contemporary musicians, are often reluctant to rely on the fair use doctrine because of its inherent uncertainty, the potentially harsh remedies for copyright infringement, and the practical inability to obtain effective pre-clearance rights. Moreover, copyright owners have no obligation under existing law to respond to a cumulative creator’s inquiry. Thus, a familiar refrain in professional creative communities is “if in doubt, leave it out.” In this Article we propose a novel mechanism that would …

Copyright And Freedom Of Expression: Saving Free Speech From Advancing Legislation, Amanda B. Cook

Amanda B Cook

The Supreme Court has expressly recognized the possibility of a First Amendment defense to copyright infringement claims, but it has never actually found such a defense to apply to a case before it. And nearly every year, Congress enacts or attempts to enact more legislation that restricts speech under the banner of the copyright clause. The problem is that the natural right of free speech is being depleted by the legislatively granted right of intellectual property, putting both individual liberty and the public good at risk. Congress and the courts both must begin to remember that in the common law …

Reviving The Gatekeeping Function: Optimizing The Exclusion Potential Of Subject Matter Eligibility, Maayan Filmar-Perel

maayan filmar

Today, many patents that fail the constitutional mandate “[to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts” are issued. Patents are granted irrespective of whether they are actually needed to incentivize innovation.

Consequently, many patent grants fail to reflect an appropriate balance between the ex post costs of short-term monopoly and the benefits of higher ex ante incentives to innovate. Other patents are issued without having any prospected commercial use, so no one actually makes an economically beneficial use of them. The worst of these are those that are sought solely for the purpose of initiating infringement lawsuits and extorting …

Crowdsourcing Indie Movies, Henry H. Perritt Jr.

Henry H. Perritt, Jr.

Crowdsourcing Indie Movies

Henry H. Perritt, Jr.

Abstract

Internet-centered technology developments are revolutionizing the ways in which movies can be made. The use of crowdsourcing to make indie movies is a possibility that has not yet been explored fully, although the use of crowdsourcing to raise money for artistic works is growing. Crowdsourcing can be used for every step of making a movie, increasing the range of collaboration available to creators and reducing capital requirements. The article uses a fictional account of a team of young moviemakers to explain how they can use crowdsourcing for each step of making their …

Toward Cyber Peace: Managing Cyber Attacks Through Polycentric Governance, Scott Shackelford

Scott Shackelford

Views range widely about the seriousness of cyber attacks and the likelihood of cyber war. But even framing cyber attacks within the context of a loaded category like war can be an oversimplification that shifts focus away from enhancing cybersecurity against the full range of threats now facing companies, countries, and the international community. Current methods are proving ineffective at managing cyber attacks, and as cybersecurity legislation is being debated in the U.S. Congress and around the world the time is ripe for a fresh look at this critical topic. This Article searches for alternative avenues to foster cyber peace …

Much Ado About Something -- An Empirical Analysis Of Trademarks As Keywords, David Franklyn, David Hyman

David J. Franklyn

Disgruntled trademark owners have filed more than one hundred lawsuits in the United States and Europe, claiming that their trademarks should not be sold by search engines for use as keywords. Despite the volume of litigation, there has been little independent empirical work on consumer goals and expectations when they use trademarks as search terms; on whether consumers are actually confused by search results; and on which entities are buying trademarks as keywords. Instead, judges have relied heavily on their own intuitions, based on little more than armchair empiricism, to resolve such matters.

We report on the results of a …

Much Ado About Something -- An Empirical Analysis Of Trademarks As Keywords, David J. Franklyn, David Hyman

David J. Franklyn

Disgruntled trademark owners have filed hundreds of lawsuits in the United States and Europe claiming that search engines should not be permitted to sell their trademarks to competitors for use as keywords. Despite the volume of litigation, there has been almost no independent empirical work on the goals and expectations of consumers when they use trademarks as keyword search terms. There has also been little or no work on whether consumers are actually confused by competitor-purchased ads. And there has been no reported investigation identifying the types of entities that purchase trademarks as keywords. In this paper, we report on …

Prometheus And The Natural Phenomenon Doctrine: Let’S Not Lose Sight Of The Forest For The Trees, Samantak Ghosh

Samantak Ghosh

The Supreme Court’s recent decision on patentable subject matter, Mayo Collaborative Services. v. Prometheus Laboratories, has come in for a lot of criticism from the biotechnology industry. Whenever the Supreme Court renders a judgment that is a significant departure from the past and arguably gets it wrong, the voices questioning the underlying principle behind the decision become stronger. Unfortunately, Prometheus was a poor vehicle for recalibrating a doctrine that has been untouched for the past three decades. However, it is important to dissociate the specific opinion from the principle animating the opinion, the natural phenomenon doctrine. If the natural phenomenon …

Crowdsourcing A Trademark: What The Public Giveth, The Courts May Taketh Away, Llewellyn Joseph Gibbons

Llewellyn Joseph Gibbons

There is a long tradition of trademark holders relying on the public to create designations that they then adopt as trademark. Historically, this has been a long slow process. From the individual’s use of the term, to the acquisition of secondary meaning could take years. Web 2.0 social media has the potential to speed up this process. Frequently, these are nicknames for well-known brands, so they are potentially quite valuable. Trademark law is ambiguous regarding who owns a designation created by the public, if the individual claiming the mark have not appropriated the mark by actually using it in commerce. …

Reviving The Gatekeeping Function, Maayan Filmar-Perel

maayan filmar

Today, many patents that fail the constitutional mandate “[to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts” are issued. Patents are granted irrespective of whether they are actually needed to incentivize innovation.

Consequently, many patent grants fail to reflect an appropriate balance between the ex post costs of short-term monopoly and the benefits of higher ex ante incentives to innovate. Other patents are issued without having any prospected commercial use, so no one actually makes an economically beneficial use of them. The worst of these are those that are sought solely for the purpose of initiating infringement lawsuits and extorting …

Reviving The Gatekeeping Function, Maayan Filmar-Perel

maayan filmar

Today, many patents that fail the constitutional mandate “[to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts” are issued. Patents are granted irrespective of whether they are actually needed to incentivize innovation. Consequently, many patent grants fail to reflect an appropriate balance between the ex post costs of short-term monopoly and the benefits of higher ex ante incentives to innovate. Other patents are issued without having any prospected commercial use, so no one actually makes an economically beneficial use of them. The worst of these are those that are sought solely for the purpose of initiating infringement lawsuits and extorting …

Reviving The Gatekeeping Function, Maayan Filmar

maayan filmar

Today, many patents that fail the constitutional mandate “[to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts” are issued. Patents are granted irrespective of whether they are actually needed to incentivize innovation. Consequently, many patent grants fail to reflect an appropriate balance between the ex post costs of short-term monopoly and the benefits of higher ex ante incentives to innovate. Other patents are issued without having any prospected commercial use, so no one actually makes an economically beneficial use of them. The worst of these are those that are sought solely for the purpose of initiating infringement lawsuits and extorting …

A Conversation On Judicial Decision-Making, Robin Feldman

Robin C Feldman

Both breathtakingly broad and minutely particular, the doctrine of patentable subject matter asks us to consider which innovations are of the type for which we might grant protection. Do we include living creatures, for example, or genes? Are computer algorithms included, and just what is an algorithm anyway? These are the types of questions that the Supreme Court has considered in a number of recent cases on patentable subject matter.

Looking closely at the recent cases, a fascinating conversation emerges between the Supreme Court and the Federal Circuit. It is a conversation not just about the nature of patents, but …

Consumers: The (Still) Missing Piece In A Piecemeal Approach To Privacy, Clark Asay

Clark Asay

U.S. consumers have little actual control over how companies collect, use, and disclose their personal information. This paper identifies two specific instances of this lack of control under U.S. law related to third-party disclosures, what I call the Incognito and Onward Transfer Problems. It then identifies the types of privacy harms that result and examines the advantages and possible drawbacks of a model law aimed at addressing these specific problems. The model law is based on a system of consumer notice and choice, the predominant method used in the U.S. to provide consumers with control over their information. Up until …

Outlawed Art: Finding A Home For Graffiti In Copyright Law, Nicole A. Grant

Nicole A Grant

An intractable tension exists between the existence of graffiti as iconoclastic youth expression and the emergence of its recognition as an art form, and the boundaries of American copyright law. As graffiti gains more traction in the mainstream art world, copyright law has come to frame much of the discussion surrounding the rights that stem from (and that are overlooked by) the creation of these works. While graffiti is heralded for its uniqueness, it also thrives in a culture of appropriation that encourages dialogue among graffiti artists, in addition to establishing as the norm the pilfering of everyday cultural referents …

A Case For Legal Protection For Scientific Theories, Deepak Gupta

Deepak Gupta

This paper explores the idea of providing legal protection to scientific theories. The patent protection coverage has been extended to new technology areas such as genetically modified life forms, plants, semiconductor masks etc. However, scientific theories have been excluded from any form of legal protection, although they provide basic instruments of facilitating new developments in science and technology. Given, the current degradation in research in fundamental sciences, it is a suitable time to assess the reasons for the exclusion and determine if there is a need to provide any protection to the ‘Scientific Theories’. Further, in case legal protection is …

Illuminating Innovation: From Patent Racing To Patent War, Lea B. Shaver

Lea Shaver

Patent law assumes that stronger protection boosts innovation. Yet empirical evidence to test this “innovation hypothesis” is lacking. This Article argues that historical case studies hold unique promise to provide an empirical foundation to patent law. The Article then offers such a case study focused on electrification. Specifically, this Article uses the history of patent prosecution and litigation surrounding the lightbulb to examine a recently articulated theory of “patent racing” as a justification for patent protection.

As put forth by Mark Lemley, racing theory suggests that patent protection raises the stakes of being the first to reach a technological milestone, …

The Cloud: Boundless Digital Potential Or Enclosure 3.0?, David Lametti

David Lametti

The Cloud presents enormous potential for users to have access to facilities such as vast data storage and infinite computing capacity. Yet the Cloud, taken from the perspective of the average user, does have a dark side. I agree with a number of writers and the concerns that they raise about privacy and personal autonomy on the internet and the Cloud. However, I wish to voice concern over another change. From the perspective of users, the Cloud might also reduce the range of user possibilities for robust interaction with the internet/Cloud in a manner which then prevents users from participating …

Offensive Venue: The Curious Use Of Declaratory Judgment To Forum Shop In Patent Litigation, Chester S. Chuang

Chester S. Chuang

Forum shopping is widespread in patent litigation because there are clear differences in outcomes among the various federal districts. An accused patent infringer that is sued in a particularly disadvantageous forum can file a motion to transfer to a more convenient forum, but the general consensus is that such motions are difficult to win. Accordingly, accused infringers often file declaratory judgment actions to forum shop. Such actions allow accused infringers to preemptively sue the patent owner in the accused infringer’s preferred forum, and are considered by many to be the best way for accused infringers to play the forum shopping …

Brands As Food For Thought: The Case For Regulating Food Brands, Amir H. Khoury

Amir Khoury

Every brand, in its original capacity as a trademark, is intended to identify and to differentiate a certain type of product or service from other competing products or services. This is the original purpose of marks. But, over time, this (original) purpose has been overrun by a different reality. Food Brands now harness a dual power or impact. The first refers to their Market Impact i.e. their ability to overshadow competing brands, and the other relates to their Consumption Impact; i.e. their ability to generate wants and to shape the image of the foods that we consume. This is not …

Is The Middle East Moving Toward Islamism After The Arab Spring? The Case Study Of The Egyptian Commercial And Financial Laws, Radwa S. Elsaman Ms., Ahmed Eldakak Mr.

Radwa S Elsaman

The parliamentary elections that followed the Egyptian Revolution witnessed an unprecedented success for Islamists as they secured an overwhelming majority of seats, suggesting that they may intend to amend many laws to bring it in compliance with the Islamic Shari’a. This article addresses legal challenges that will face the new majority if they decide to Islamize laws and regulations related to business and finance. Particularly, the article discusses Islamic money theory, trade, banking systems, consumer protection, insurance, competition, and tax systems. The article analyzes the Egyptian business and finance laws to examine whether they comply with Islamic law. It then …

Copyright And Moral Norms, Alina Ng

Alina Ng

The role normative principles such as morality and ethics play in a legal system is a highly contentious point in jurisprudence and legal theory. Scholars and philosophers have often disagreed on whether laws should reflect and incorporate moral and ethical norms. The idea that there could be a necessary connection between law and objective morality has been forthrightly rejected by some jurists because of the heterogeneity of social views and beliefs about what is right and wrong conduct. This paper challenges the assertion by legal positivism that morality cannot be incorporated into legal analysis because they obfuscate analytical thinking about …

News On The Internet, Robert C. Denicola

Robert C Denicola

No abstract provided.

News On The Internet, Robert C. Denicola

Robert C Denicola

No abstract provided.

A Comparative Study On Human Embryonic Stem Cell's Patent-Eligibility In The United States, The European Patent Organization And China, Huan Zhu

Huan Zhu

Since human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) have entered the public’s view, a large number of ethical debates and moral concerns have been generated. However, these concerns have not stifled advances in biotechnology regarding hESCs. Thanks to its scientific potential and therapeutic values, scientists from all over the world contribute both funding and time to investigate hESCs and additionally seek protection for their research inventions and methods. The patent system is a known mechanism to provide this protection and promote science by granting the patentee exclusive rights to the inventions while requiring public disclosure. However, due to the intrinsic relation of …

News On The Internet, Robert C. Denicola

Robert C Denicola

No abstract provided.

News On The Internet, Robert C. Denicola

Robert C Denicola

No abstract provided.

On Patent Policy And A Strictly Construed Written Description, Mario G. Menocal

Mario G. Menocal

The Federal Circuit’s 2010 decision in Ariad Pharmaceuticals v. Eli Lilly, re-ignited a polemic within the judiciary and academia concerning how language in 35 U.S.C. § 112, ¶ 1 providing for the written description should be applied. Some believe the written description should be strictly construed so as to deny property over anything not described even though it might be enabled. Others believe the written description should be read liberally, extending patent scope out to cover anything that is arguably enabled. Where history, precedent, and legal reasoning are unavailing in searching for an answer, an review of patent law’s policy …

News On The Internet, Robert C. Denicola

Robert C Denicola

No abstract provided.