Jurisprudence Commons^™

To Punish Or To Restore? A False Alternative, Serge Gutwirth, Paul De Hert

Serge Gutwirth

The authors claim that restorative justice is mainly an ideological movement that lacks convincing empirical, anthropological or legal grounds. Instead of trying to make criminal law more restorative, or even trying to replace penal law by an alternative system of restorative law, restorative thinkers had better turn to the opportunities that the civil law offers for ‘horizontal’ conflict resolution. Their critique of restorativist ideology does not imply that the authors want to defend criminal justice as it is administered today in Western Europe, to the contrary. On the one hand the scope of criminal law could and should be drastically …