Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Digital Commons Network

Open Access. Powered by Scholars. Published by Universities.®

Articles 1 - 30 of 225

Full-Text Articles in Entire DC Network

Front Matter, Michigan Law Review Dec 1938

Front Matter, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

Front Matter for Volume 37, Issue 2 of Michigan Law Review


Schools - Private Parochial Schools - Transportation Of Pupils - Use Of Public Funds, Fred C. Newman Dec 1938

Schools - Private Parochial Schools - Transportation Of Pupils - Use Of Public Funds, Fred C. Newman

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff taxpayers instituted proceedings to restrain defendant board of education from complying with a statute which required defendant board of education to expend public funds for the purpose of transporting pupils to and from a parochial school. Held, that the statute was invalid as violative of the provision of the state constitution which prohibited the use of any public money "directly or indirectly" in aid of any sectarian school, and plaintiffs were entitled to judgment upon the pleadings; three judges dissented. Judd v. Board of Education of Union Free School Dist. No. 2, 278 N. Y. 200, 15 …


Negligence - Liability For Emotional Disturbance, William K. Jackson Dec 1938

Negligence - Liability For Emotional Disturbance, William K. Jackson

Michigan Law Review

Defendant negligently sold unlabeled poisoned bran, thereby causing the death of or permanent injury to the buyer's cows, and the loss of his dairy business. As a result of this calamity, the buyer died from a decompensated heart caused by emotional distress and nervous shock. The buyer had commenced action for damages and it is continued here by his wife as administratrix of his estate. Held, recovery may be had for the buyer's death. Rasmussen v. Benson, (Neb. 1938) 280 N. W. 890.


Criminal Law And Procedure - Admissibility Of Confessions - Exhortations To Tell The Truth, Dan K. Cook Dec 1938

Criminal Law And Procedure - Admissibility Of Confessions - Exhortations To Tell The Truth, Dan K. Cook

Michigan Law Review

Defendant, while in the custody of police officers, confessed to the crime of murder. It was shown that the police officers during the course of defendant's examination, stated to the defendant that "it was better for him to tell the whole truth," and ''You are not telling the truth, give us the truth on this," "You might as well tell the truth; to me now," "I advise you to tell the truth in this case." In the subsequent prosecution of the defendant for murder, it was held that the confession was properly admissible notwithstanding these statements by the officers. Commonwealth …


Taxation - Income Tax - Surtax On Income Of Corporation Where Profits Are Accumulated To Avoid Surtax On Income Of Its Shareholders - Construction, Brackley Shaw Dec 1938

Taxation - Income Tax - Surtax On Income Of Corporation Where Profits Are Accumulated To Avoid Surtax On Income Of Its Shareholders - Construction, Brackley Shaw

Michigan Law Review

Section 104 of the Revenue Act of 1928 imposed a surtax on the net income of any corporation "formed or availed of for the purpose of preventing the imposition of the surtax on its shareholders through the medium of permitting its gains and profits to accumulate instead of being divided and distributed," and provided that "the fact that the gains or profits are permitted to accumulate beyond the reasonable needs of the business shall be prima facie evidence of a purpose to escape the surtax." Defendant corporation was formed in 1911 with $200,000 capital stock all owned by Kohl. In …


The Widow's Right Of Election In The Estate Of Her Husband, Elbridge D. Phelps Dec 1938

The Widow's Right Of Election In The Estate Of Her Husband, Elbridge D. Phelps

Michigan Law Review

Before launching into the discussion proper, and in order to avoid confusion and misunderstanding later on, it is deemed wise at once to mark out boundaries within which it is proposed to confine the treatment of the subject here involved. Accordingly, in that which follows, attention will be centered largely on the necessity for election by a widow under modern statutes which allow her to take against her husband's will, and on the effects of her election or non-election upon her interest in her husband's estate. In so far as a surviving husband has identical rights, they will be adverted …


Securities Legislation - Accounting Practice And The Securities Act Of 1933, Paul R. Trigg Jr. Dec 1938

Securities Legislation - Accounting Practice And The Securities Act Of 1933, Paul R. Trigg Jr.

Michigan Law Review

Item 25 of the registration regulations under the Securities Act of 1933 requires the registrant to "submit balance sheets . . . as of a date within ninety days of the filing of the registration statement." The approximate form which such balance sheets are to take is indicated in the regulations, as well as the manner of certification required. So far as the form of the balance sheet proper is concerned, it is doubtful whether item 54 presents any new or startling innovations, but when the balance sheet and the supplementary schedules required to be appended thereto are considered, it …


Criminal Law And Procedure - Physicians And Surgeons - Contraceptive Statutes And Implied Exceptions Thereto, Thomas K. Fisher Dec 1938

Criminal Law And Procedure - Physicians And Surgeons - Contraceptive Statutes And Implied Exceptions Thereto, Thomas K. Fisher

Michigan Law Review

A Massachusetts statute made the selling of any drug, medicine or instrument for the prevention of conception a criminal offense. The defendants, a doctor, a nurse, and two social workers, all connected with a charitable association, prescribed and sold contraceptives to non-pregnant, married women. Defendants' offer of proof, admitting the facts charged, but contending that the statute did not apply where the sale was made under a physician's prescription for the preservation of life or health, was found by the trial court to constitute no defense. Held, that the wording was plain and unequivocal allowing for no implied exception. …


Torts - Recovery For Emotional Disturbance Unaccompanied By Physical Injury, Michigan Law Review Dec 1938

Torts - Recovery For Emotional Disturbance Unaccompanied By Physical Injury, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

Appellee brought an action in tort to recover damages for mental anguish suffered when appellant had an autopsy performed upon the body of her deceased husband. Appellant had been requested to perform the postmortem by decedent's employer, who was authorized under the state workmen's compensation act to require an autopsy. The act also provided that no autopsy should be held without notice first being given to the widow or next of kin and an opportunity given to have a representative present to witness the same. The only effect under the act of a failure to give notice was to render …


The Public Interest Concept In Law And In Economics, Robert W. Harbeson Dec 1938

The Public Interest Concept In Law And In Economics, Robert W. Harbeson

Michigan Law Review

It is an interesting and perhaps important coincidence that only a year previous to the famous decision in Nebbia v. New York there appeared two volumes which together constitute an equally notable landmark in the development of economic doctrine, Professor Edward Chamberlin's Theory of Monopolistic Competition and Mrs. Joan Robinson's Economics of Imperfect Competition. While there is no evidence that the latter works influenced the outcome of the Nebbia case, the writer is of the opinion that these studies not only afford a rationale of that decision but also make desirable a re-examination of the concept of "businesses affected …


The Doctrine Of Administrative Trespass In French Law: An Analogue Of Due Process, Armin Uhler Dec 1938

The Doctrine Of Administrative Trespass In French Law: An Analogue Of Due Process, Armin Uhler

Michigan Law Review

The French droit administratif, since Dicey's critical and unsympathetic comments in his lectures and works on the English constitution, has continued to attract a great deal of interest in the English-speaking world. In this country the more recent references to the system known by that name are prompted by something more than academic curiosity. Unprecedented expansion of administrative activity, particularly on the part of the federal government, has focused attention on many problems which have become acute because of that fact. Unquestionably, one of the most vexing among them is the question of review of administrative action upon the …


Liens - Extent To Which Common-Law Artisan's Lien Has Been Supplanted By Statute, Arthur P. Boynton Dec 1938

Liens - Extent To Which Common-Law Artisan's Lien Has Been Supplanted By Statute, Arthur P. Boynton

Michigan Law Review

An artisan's lien is the right of a bailee, who by his labor, skill, or material adds value to the chattel of another at the request of the owner, directly or impliedly, to retain possession of the chattel until the reasonable value of his services has been paid. The right to this lien, which is a specific lien, is of common-law origin, and in the absence of anything inconsistent in the contract has long been extended to all artisans. This common-law artisan's lien, however, has been supplanted by statute in some respect in all but five states. In the other …


Limitation Of Actions - Contempt Proceedings, Menefee D. Blackwell Dec 1938

Limitation Of Actions - Contempt Proceedings, Menefee D. Blackwell

Michigan Law Review

The application of statutes of limitation to proceedings for criminal or civil contempt involves some obscurity and confusion in the modern cases. Legislation has rarely provided expressly for the limitation of contempt proceedings, and their hybrid character has made it difficult to rely with confidence on analogies. The modern tendency of courts has been to differentiate between criminal and civil contempts for many purposes. While the tests for distinguishing civil and criminal proceedings are not yet clear, it seems that the application of limitation acts depends very largely on this distinction.


Adverse Possession - Requirements For Obtaining Title To A Cave By Adverse Possession, Donald M. Swope Dec 1938

Adverse Possession - Requirements For Obtaining Title To A Cave By Adverse Possession, Donald M. Swope

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff and defendant were owners of adjoining properties. On defendant's land was located the only opening to a cavern, which a remote grantor of defendant discovered in 1893. Since that time, defendant and its immediate and remote grantors have improved the cave for visitors, and conducted persons through it upon the payment of an admission price. With wide publicity, this has continued for almost fifty years. Plaintiff first visited the cave in 1895, paying an admission fee for the privilege, and has visited it several times since. A part of said cave extended under real estate owned by plaintiff, but …


Adverse Possession - Severance Of Minerals And Surface - Adverse Possession As Affecting Title To The Minerals, John M. Ulman Dec 1938

Adverse Possession - Severance Of Minerals And Surface - Adverse Possession As Affecting Title To The Minerals, John M. Ulman

Michigan Law Review

The land in question was set aside by the state for school purposes. For some time prior to 1881 one Bailey had been in possession. At that time he and his children, to whom he had deeded parts of the land, conveyed the mineral interests to a grantee from whom plaintiff claims. At the time of the conveyance the evidence was insufficient to show title by adverse possession in Bailey. Bailey and his grantees, from whom defendant claims, remained in possession until this action was brought. The limitation ceased running against the state by an act of the legislature at …


Arrest - Stopping And Questioning As An Arrest - Reasonable Suspicion From Facts Disclosed By Questioning As Justification, Robert Meisenholder Dec 1938

Arrest - Stopping And Questioning As An Arrest - Reasonable Suspicion From Facts Disclosed By Questioning As Justification, Robert Meisenholder

Michigan Law Review

After arrest of the defendant on mere suspicion without probable cause, the arresting officers on searching the car in which he was driving found two guns. The defendant complained on appeal, after conviction for carrying concealed weapons in an automobile, of the denial of his motion before trial to suppress the evidence. Held, it was error to refuse to suppress the guns as evidence because, the arrest being unlawful, the subsequent search and seizure was unlawful. Had the officers stopped and questioned the defendant, and had such questioning disclosed facts to establish a reasonable suspicion that the defendant was …


Corporations - Disregarding Corporate Entity - Fraud, Collins E. Brooks Dec 1938

Corporations - Disregarding Corporate Entity - Fraud, Collins E. Brooks

Michigan Law Review

A and B purchased from plaintiffs all of the stock of defendant corporation. Prior to the transaction, and as a basis for negotiations, plaintiffs had an accountant prepare a statement of corporate assets and liabilities, which showed that the corporation was in financial difficulties. A and B acknowledged the corporate indebtedness and took over the corporation. Later, plaintiffs brought suit against the corporation on claims for salaries and advancements allegedly due them from it, which claims had not appeared on the statement of corporate liabilities. Held, the corporate entity would be disregarded, and plaintiffs estopped from setting up their …


Injunctions - Labor Unions - Enforcement Of Employer's Closed Shop Agreement, Michigan Law Review Dec 1938

Injunctions - Labor Unions - Enforcement Of Employer's Closed Shop Agreement, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff unions entered into an agreement with the defendants by the terms of which the defendants were to employ union men, all of whom were to be furnished by the Bricklayers Central Employment Bureau at certain wages and for certain hours. Contrary to the agreement, the defendants employed nonunion men of their own selection and at lower wages and for longer hours than provided by the agreement. Plaintiff sought an injunction pendente lite on behalf of the unions to restrain defendants from disregarding the terms of the agreement. Held, motion for injunction pendente lite granted. Murphy v. Ralph, …


Insurance - Supervision By The State - What Constitutes The Insurance Business, Thomas E. Wilson Dec 1938

Insurance - Supervision By The State - What Constitutes The Insurance Business, Thomas E. Wilson

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff, a corporation, advertised that any person who bought goods from certain selected stores would be entitled to receive coupons, and when his coupons amounted to a certain sum he would be entitled to certain death and security benefits up to specified amounts. Plaintiff brought suit against the Insurance Commissioner of Pennsylvania to enjoin him from interfering with the plaintiff's business. Held, that the plaintiff was carrying on an insurance business and was subject to supervision by the Insurance Commissioner. Hunt v. Public Mutual Benefit Foundation, (C. C. A. 3d, 1938) 94 F. (2d) 749, certiorari denied (U. …


Municipal Corporations - Official Misconduct As Ground For Removal Of Officer, Leonard D. Verdier Jr. Dec 1938

Municipal Corporations - Official Misconduct As Ground For Removal Of Officer, Leonard D. Verdier Jr.

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff, a member of the council of the city of Highland Park, Michigan, was removed by the council, as provided in the charter because of membership in the Black Legion. The Black Legion was a secret society founded on principles of racial, religious, and political discrimination. Its members took an oath to further these purposes by any means ordered by the officers of the organization, including violence and terrorism. Members were forbidden to expose the organization under penalty of death, and membership was supposedly permanent. The council found that membership in such a society rendered Wilson incompetent to perform the …


Parent And Child - Duty Of Mother To Support Child When Father Is Alive, Thomas E. Wilson Dec 1938

Parent And Child - Duty Of Mother To Support Child When Father Is Alive, Thomas E. Wilson

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff obtained a divorce from defendant, and at the time of the divorce voluntarily undertook to care for and support their twenty-one year old son, who was afflicted with tuberculosis and unable to support himself. The son resided with his mother until his death. She instituted this action against the father to recover for the care and support of the son from the time of the divorce until his death and for funeral expenses, relying upon a statute imposing upon specified classes or relatives of poor persons a duty to maintain them, which statute the plaintiff contended imposed a duty …


Sales - Implied Warranty - Explosive In Cigar, James W. Mehaffy Dec 1938

Sales - Implied Warranty - Explosive In Cigar, James W. Mehaffy

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff purchased cigars from a retail merchant. The cigars were sold under a trade name and when purchased from a wholesaler by the retailer were wrapped in cellophane, and were sold to the plaintiff while still in the original wrapper. One of the cigars contained a firecracker, which exploded when plaintiff lighted the cigar, causing substantial injury. Held, that the plaintiff can recover from the retailer. Dow Drug Co. v. Nieman, 57 Ohio App. 190, 13 N. E. (2d) 130 (1936).


Taxation - Federal Estate Tax - Gift In Contemplation Of Death, Edmund O'Hare Dec 1938

Taxation - Federal Estate Tax - Gift In Contemplation Of Death, Edmund O'Hare

Michigan Law Review

Decedent, when eighty years old and while still in good health, set up an irrevocable trust of one-third of his property, with a life estate to his daughter and remainder over on the daughter's death to her children and descendants. Under the trust deed the income was to be accumulated and added to the principal until the donor's death. The Supreme Court found that decedent, who was thinking about speculating on the stock exchange, was anxious to insure adequate provision for his daughter and her descendants upon his death, and that he therefore determined to make an irrevocable disposition of …


Taxation - Federal Gift Tax - Taxability Of Interest Passing At Creation Of Tenancy By Entirety, Ben H. Dewey Dec 1938

Taxation - Federal Gift Tax - Taxability Of Interest Passing At Creation Of Tenancy By Entirety, Ben H. Dewey

Michigan Law Review

On September 20, 1933, petitioner transferred by deed realty owned by him in fee to himself and his wife as tenants by the entirety. The commissioner of internal revenue determined that the transfer constituted a taxable gift under the Gift Tax Act of 1932. Petitioner took an appeal to the Board of Tax Appeals. Held, with one dissent, that such creation of a tenancy by the entireties did not constitute a taxable transfer under the Gift Tax Act. Hart v. Commissioner, 36 B. T. A. No. 176 (Dec. 28, 1937).


Trusts - Reservation Of Life Income And Power Of Revocation In Settlor - Not Testamentary Within Mortmain Statute, Benjamin H. Dewey Dec 1938

Trusts - Reservation Of Life Income And Power Of Revocation In Settlor - Not Testamentary Within Mortmain Statute, Benjamin H. Dewey

Michigan Law Review

A settlor purported to set up a trust of certain of his property. In the trust agreement, the settlor reserved to himself the life income from the trust property, with such further amounts from the principal as the trustee, in his absolute discretion, should deem necessary for the settlor's proper maintenance and support; the power, with the approval of the trustee, to revoke or modify the trust; and the life use of the realty encompassed by the trust, on which he was to pay taxes. At the death of the settlor, certain of the trust property was to be administered …


Monthly Periodical Index, Michigan Law Review Dec 1938

Monthly Periodical Index, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

This department lists the articles and comments which appear in twenty-five leading law reviews.


Book Notes, Michigan Law Review Dec 1938

Book Notes, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

This department undertakes to list and, when possible, describe briefly current boob on law and matters closely related thereto.


Constitutional Law - Validity Of State Occupation Tax On Contractors With The Federal Government, James H. Kilbourne Nov 1938

Constitutional Law - Validity Of State Occupation Tax On Contractors With The Federal Government, James H. Kilbourne

Michigan Law Review

The increasing burden of both federal and state taxation during the past decade has multiplied the attempts by some of those affected to establish, in the courts, immunity from certain taxes. The limitations of the power of the governments to tax have, then, special significance for one who seeks, in that fashion, to challenge the imposition of a tax on himself. Two cases recently decided by the Supreme Court involved one of those limitations-that which denies to the states the power to enforce a tax which impedes the exercise of the powers of the federal government.


Labor Law - Workers Who Struck Prior To Effective Date Of National Labor Relations Act As "Employees" Within The Meaning Of Act, Edward J. Wendrow Nov 1938

Labor Law - Workers Who Struck Prior To Effective Date Of National Labor Relations Act As "Employees" Within The Meaning Of Act, Edward J. Wendrow

Michigan Law Review

Prior to the passage of the Wagner Act, respondent's employees went on strike when the respondent refused to negotiate with the union. Thereupon respondent notified them they were all discharged and that the mill was closing down. Subsequent to the effective date of the act, respondent still refused to negotiate with the union and refused to hire any strikers who would not sign a "yellow dog" contract. The National Labor Relations Board held the refusal to negotiate and the discrimination in regard to hire to be violations of section 8 (5) and (3) respectively of the act and, inter alia …


Taxation - Federal Estate Tax - Subscriptions To Charitable And Educational Institutions As Deductions From Gross Estate, Charles E. Nadeau Nov 1938

Taxation - Federal Estate Tax - Subscriptions To Charitable And Educational Institutions As Deductions From Gross Estate, Charles E. Nadeau

Michigan Law Review

Decedent had promised to contribute funds to numerous educational, religious, and charitable institutions. Some of these pledges were conditioned on pledges of third parties to perform certain duties or to furnish subscriptions to equal amounts. In several instances the institutions, on fullfillment of the conditions, acted in reliance on these promises in a manner that made them enforceable against the estate under the state law. The executor had paid some of these claims. In affirming the Board of Tax Appeals the court held that pledges, though later satisfied by the executor, cannot be deducted from the gross estate as "transfers" …