Digital Commons Network^™

Race At The Pivot Point: The Future Of Race-Based Policies To Remedy De Jure Segregation After Parents Involved In Community Schools, Jonathan D Fischbach, Will Rhee, Robert Cacace

Faculty & Staff Scholarship

This article examines the perhaps unintended consequences of changing legal doctrine. Most commentary on the U.S. Supreme Court Parents Involved in Community Schools (“PICS”) decision explores PICS’ impact upon voluntary race-based policies to remedy unintentional de facto racial segregation. In contrast, this analysis explores PICS’ impact upon mandatory race-based policies to remedy government-sponsored de jure racial segregation. After PICS, the Fourteenth Amendment’s essence and character can turn on a finding of unitary status, a purely factual and somewhat subjective determination reviewable only for clear error. Under the Equal Protection Clause, a school district found to operate a de jure segregated …