Digital Commons Network^™

Liberal Justices' Reliance On Legislative History: Principle, Strategy, And The Scalia Effect, James J. Brudney

James J. Brudney

Abstract for “Liberal Justices’ Reliance on Legislative History: Principle, Strategy, and the Scalia Effect”

This article conducts an in-depth examination of Supreme Court Justices’ reliance on legislative history during the Burger, Rehnquist, and early Roberts eras. In doing so, it makes two important contributions to current statutory interpretation debates.

First, the article presents a powerful case against the conventional wisdom that legislative history is a “politicized” resource, invoked opportunistically by federal judges. The premise that judges regularly rely on legislative history to promote their preferred policy positions—if true—should find ample support in the majority opinions of liberal Supreme Court Justices …