Digital Commons Network^™

Hostile Public Accommodations Laws And The First Amendment, Daniel Koontz

Daniel Koontz

State and municipal Human Rights Commissions have recently begun aggressively interpreting public accommodations laws to punish the speech of proprietors of bars, restaurants, country clubs, and other public accommodations. The theory is that if a proprietor says something to a customer—or even displays artwork, decorations, or signs—that could potentially offend the customer based on race, religion, sex, or ancestry, the proprietor has created a “hostile environment” which denies the customer “full and equal enjoyment” of the public accommodation.

Proprietors can face liability even in the absence of allegations that they refused service to a customer. In one case, a human …