Digital Commons Network^™

Too Subtle To Satisfy Many: Was Grotius's Teleology Of Punishment Predestined To Fail?, Jeremy Seth Geddert

Political Science Department Faculty Works

Most readers believe Grotius failed to refute Socinus in De satisfactione. This paper argues that Grotius's failure was one of reception rather than argument. It is possible to read De satisfactione as Grotius adverted: a genuine (if subtle) concept of satisfaction, and a defence of the (small-c) catholic faith. Grotius does reject a necessitarian identical satisfaction, in which a repayment is equal to a debt, but like Aquinas, he embraces a teleological equivalent satisfaction, in which a punishment fits a crime. Yet Grotius’s catholic theory was predestined not to persuade a wartime Continental audience whose centre had not held …