Digital Commons Network^™

Reclamation Of Goods From A Fradulent Buyer, Robert Braucher

Michigan Law Review

Sections 2-702(2) and (3) of the Uniform Commercial Code (Code), defining the right of a seller to reclaim goods from an insolvent buyer, have for years been the subject of controversy. The sponsors of the Code have stood firm on the basic policy of these sections for more than twenty-five years, but, in its 1966 Official Recommendations for Amendment of the Uniform Commercial Code, the Permanent Editorial Board includes an amendment striking the words "or lien creditor" from section 2-702(3). That change has already been made in six states: California, Illinois, Maine, New Jersey, New Mexico, and New York. In …

Foreign Lienor Cannot Prevail In Ohio Against Subsequent Good Faith Purchaser Who Holds Ohio Certificate Of Title- Commercial Credit Corp. V. Pottmeyer, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

Williams purchased an automobile in West Virginia from plaintiff's assignor on a conditional sales contract. The security interest was duly recorded in West Virginia and noted on the certificate of title. Before paying any of the purchase price, Williams fraudulently procured another West Virginia certificate of title free of notice of liens. Relying on the fraudulent certificate, the defendant bought the car from Williams at an Ohio automobile auction and obtained an Ohio certificate of title. The plaintiff brought suit in Ohio to recover the vehicle and obtained a favorable judgment, which was affirmed by an Ohio court of appeals. …

A Radical Restatement Of The Law Of Seller's Damages: Michigan Results Compared, Robert J. Harris

Michigan Law Review

Conventional doctrine does not address itself directly to the choice among valuation techniques, although the various parochial damage formulae give some clues. Underlying this series of articles is an assumption that the doctrine makes more sense when restated in valuation terms. These articles involve an effort to restate in such terms one sector of expectation damage law-the part that governs cases in which plaintiff is a "seller."

A General Theory For Measuring Seller's Damages For Total Breach Of Contract, Robert J. Harris

Michigan Law Review

This article is concerned with the legal rules which should govern the process of valuing what plaintiff saved by exercising his power to stop further performance upon notice of defendant's serious breach. Where plaintiff is a "buyer" (whether he buys land, services, personality, or the temporary use of some kind of property), and he was to pay the price in dollars, few difficulties arise in valuing his saved performance. But if he was a "seller" of any of those commodities, valuation is hard. Thus our inquiry is chiefly concerned with cases in which plaintiff is a "seller," not a "buyer."

Document Of Title: A Comparison Of The Uniform Commercial Code And Other Uniform Acts, With Emphasis On Michigan Law, Douglass Boshkoff

Michigan Law Review

Although this article is mainly oriented toward the legal materials of one jurisdiction, the presence of a fairly common background of uniform acts makes it relevant to other jurisdictions, except where there are contrary interpretations of a particular statutory provision. Therefore, parallel citations to the various uniform acts have been provided with the hope that this article will be of assistance to other groups attempting to evaluate article seven of the Uniform Commercial Code.

Sales - Breach Of Warranty - Notice Required By Section 49 Of Uniform Sales Act Must Be Given To Seller Or His Agent, Thomas A. Troyer S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Defendant corporation ordered certain boiler burner units through Burke, the selling agent of a boiler manufacturer. The order having been transmitted by Burke to plaintiff, the manufacturer's exclusive distributer in the area, the burner units were delivered. Defendant discovered certain defects in their specifications, notified Burke to this effect, and withheld payment of part of the purchase price. In an action by plaintiff for this unpaid balance of the agreed price, defendant asserted plaintiff's breach of warranty by way of recoupment. On appeal of the trial court's judgment for plaintiff, held, affirmed. Defendant could not successfully claim breach of …

Sales - Transfer Of Title - Effect Of Motor Vehicle Act, Charles G. Williamson, Jr. S.Ed.

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiffs, wholesale automobile dealers in New Mexico and Colorado, each sold a used car to a Utah dealer. The wholesalers forwarded drafts, with certificates of title attached, for payment by the dealer. The dealer sold the cars from his lot without ever having paid the drafts, and, consequently, without ever having. obtained the foreign title certificates. Plaintiffs brought replevin against the purchasers of the autos and recovered judgments. On appeal, held, reversed. The wholesalers knew that the purchaser was a used car dealer. They had transferred more than mere possession and clothed him with apparent ownership. Therefore, under the …

Contracts-Duty To Mitigate Damages Upon Anticipatory Breach Of Forward Contract Of Sale, William F. Snyder

Michigan Law Review

The theory of our law in regard to damages for breach of contract has been to give the innocent party as nearly as possible what he would have received had the contract been performed. To this end, our courts have worked out a rough formula which has been described by Professor Grismore as follows:

" ... The promisee is, in general, entitled to recover the economic equivalent of the performance promised, at the time and place fixed in the contract, plus any losses incurred or gains prevented through not receiving it, less any savings that have resulted to the promisee …

Constitutional Law-A Federal Commercial Code-Some Possibilities Under The Constitution, Merrill N. Johnson

Michigan Law Review

It is the purpose of this comment to examine various possibilities of federal action which would help to bring about unification, simplification and clarification in the field of commercial law. The term "commercial law" has no commonly accepted connotation; it is taken here to ·include the law of transfers of personal property by commercial methods, of negotiable instruments, of chattel securities, of agency and of business associations; in short, all those fields of law which a Continental lawyer would term "private commercial law."

Sales - Warranty - Significance Of Phrase "Reasonably Fit For Purpose"

Michigan Law Review

The purchaser of a mechanical corn picker sued to recover the money paid for it, alleging that the seller had warranted that the machine was reasonably fit for the purpose whereas in use it missed a third of the ears, shelled some of those it did pick, husked others poorly and knocked down standing corn. The appellate court reversed a judgment for the defendant seller, because the trial court had instructed the jury that the warranty required only that the machine should do the work as satisfactorily as other mechanical pickers of that time would do it. Juvland V. Wood …

Sales - Implied Warranty By Victualler, Michigan Law Review

Michigan Law Review

Plaintiff purchased a meal at defendant's restaurant, in connection with which he was served contaminated drinking water obtained from defendant's well; he became ill from drinking the water. Plaintiff sued on the theory of implied warranty by defendant of the fitness of the water sold under the Uniform Sales Act, and on the ground that the service of the contaminated water in violation of the Ohio Pure Food Law constituted negligence by defendant. Held, plaintiff may recover on either theory. Yochem v. Gloria, Inc., 134 Ohio St. 427, 17 N. E. (2d) 731 (1938).

Sales - Implied Warranty Of Fitness - Restaurateur

Michigan Law Review

Defendant, proprietor of a hotel and dining room, served unwholesome food to the plaintiff who became ill as a result of its impurity. The plaintiff sued for the damages resulting from his illness, on the theory that there was an implied warranty that the food was fit for human consumption. Held, the serving of food for immediate consumption on the premises was not a "sale" within the Uniform Sales Act, and therefore there was no warranty attached under the terms of the Act, and there was no implied warranty of fitness of food so served at common law. Lynch …

Sales-Implied Warranty Of Fitness Under Uniform Act

Michigan Law Review

Defendants, being in need of a coal stoker that would accomplish a particular purpose, made their desires known to plaintiffs. Plaintiffs sold defendants a certain stoker under its trade name, assuring them that it would accomplish their purpose. Defendants were entire.ly ignorant as to the ability or capacity of the stoker and did not know that it even had a trade name, and plaintiffs made the sale knowing that defendants were unfamiliar with the equipment and its operation. The Uniform Sales Act, in force in the jurisdiction, provides in subd. 1 that where the buyer reveals the purpose for which …